You are reading Urdu Translation or English translation of four Imams research. I have seen there are many people who have translated their books does not have solid understanding of the language. If someone has written in English then they translated in Urdu and if someone is written in Urdu it is then trnaslated in English
Discussing these kind of topics is pollouting youths mind, if original poster was interested inthis topic he/she could have gone to a scholar and clarified this.
How many scholars are sitting on google, all of us copying and pasting it without checking the sources if they belong to authenic organisations or not.
I know everyone in this forum does not just copy and paste but there are peoplewho are just copying and pasting and all these people are reading pasted info and becoming astray we will be responsible for them. Therefore it’s our duty if someone is asking a question like the current post we should anser him or her by PM and close the thread. These kind of threads or topics should not be open for discussion in public.