Re: Afridi: don't let the door hit you on the way out
English cricket is structured and regularized, but you say they are over coached. We must not be against a good idea just coz someone else came up with it. ( paraphrasing Bill Clinton here ). The point I am making is, IPL has helped Indians. Many here will agree it not only helped them with the sport but also with money and power. If we cannot do something similar in Pakistan, then why not take advantage of what is already out there. There is another danger here; if we don't act now chances are the opportunity that opened up to take charge of ICC will be lost and we will forever live under Indian hegemony.
Firstly, structured and regularised domestic cricket is not a synonym for over coaching! England messed up the equation for themselves, and that's their problem.
Secondly, BBCI - a very organised and accountable board with a young energetic cricket team playing under a dynamic and supremely talented captain preceded IPL! India has a comparatively much better domestic structure and rigorous selection committee. That's the reason despite all their larger than life batting legends pretty much retiring (or slowing down) at the same time, the team does not really go through the what they call a 'struggling transition phase' (a phase which has been conveniently clouding over team Pakistan for God knows how many years - it's a mother of all excuses for repeated pathetic performances).
Thirdly, likes of Kohli, Raina, Sharma, Gambir etc etc did not come in Indian team through IPL. These players were already part of Indian bench strength way before the emergence of IPL, and performing at international stage at the level that established them as most deserving replacement of their batting greats. Again they were product of Indian first class cricket and accountable selection committee.
Fourthly, just because IPL gives special preference to their own domestic top scorers. What makes you think such lucrative league will be willing to take in your substandard bits and pieces players and throw money on them? I am sorry, other than Afridi (thanks to his star power and IPL is all about star power), there is not a single player in Pakistan international cricket team who can easily get an IPL contract. Maybe you can say Akmal Jr, but what about the rest of the team?
Besides, Afridi who had literally played in every single international T20 league out there, how much of that 'international exposure' had transformed his game and made him a 'better' player?
So yes, there is no quick cosmetic fix to transform the below average bits and pieces players you have in the team. If you want to save the game of cricket from becoming a dying sport in the country, you'll have to instil some energy and competitiveness into domestic cricket. It is about training the current and future generation of aspiring young cricketers, not setting up a system to teach Kamran Akaml how to catch a ball after playing 13 years of international cricket.