Afghan TV Bans Women Singers

Afghan TV Bans Women Singers

KABUL, January 16 (IslamOnline.net & News Agencies) – Strong protests from the Afghan Supreme Court, Kabul TV has decided to stop showing female singers for the time being, an executive said Friday, January 16.

After breaking a decade-long ban and airing images of a woman singing on Afghanistan’s state-run television earlier in the week, the Afghan Supreme Court -which favors the imposition of Islamic Sharia laws in the war-torn country – stepped in, according to Agence France-Presse (AFP).

But the Court’s interference has also prompted criticism from women leaders who say the court has no right to intervene.

“No official decision has been taken, however, we feel the current circumstances are not suitable to air women singing,” said Azizullah Aryanfar, programming chief of Kabul TV.

He told AFP the television station had not received a letter from the court preventing it from airing such programs but confirmed that Kabul TV has decided to stop showing females singing “at least for the time being.”

The court is dominated by the conservative former Mujahadeen or anti-Soviet fighters.

“We knew this kind of move might be too early, and is not acceptable in the many conservative circles which have strong influence in the country,” Aryanfar said, referring to the former Mujahadeen leaders which form the backbone of President Hamid Karzai’s U.S.-backed government.

On Monday night, Kabul TV featured old footage of Salma, a star from the 1970s, singing a ballad about being a refugee. Instead of being totally covered up, she wore a simple head scarf.

Her five-minute appearance on the small screen came just days after Afghanistan’s loya jirga or grand assembly approved a new constitution which states that men and women have equal rights and duties under law.

Deputy Chief Justice Fazal Ahamd Manawi told AFP Thursday that the Supreme Court had sent a letter to the Ministry of Information and Kabul TV asking them to stop broadcasting women singing and dancing.

On Friday the Minister of Information and Culture Sayed Makhdoom Raheen said “there is no discrimination and there will be no discrimination” in the arts.

However, he refused to say whether there would be more images of women singing on television.

“You can find out for yourself by watching TV,” he told AFP.

Women’s Affairs Minister Habiba Surabi said she condemned the Supreme Court’s action.

“The Supreme Court interferes in issues which are not their business, they want to impose their views on people,” Surabi told AFP.

"I didn’t see any thing un-Islamic in Ms. Salma’s footage; she was just sitting politely and singing.

“Considering our traditions, we don’t want women to sing the same way as they do in western countries but the way Ms. Salma did was not against our Afghan culture.”

The ban on women singing and dancing had been imposed for more than a decade after the Mujahadeen took power in Kabul following the toppling of a communist government in 1992.

The Taliban regime, toppled by the U.S. late 2001, banned all television broadcasting after taking power in 1996 as part of its strict imposition of Islamic Sharia law.

Women’s rights activist Soraya Parlika said any decision to ban women singing on television violated Afghanistan’s new constitution.

“It’s obvious, I condemn the Supreme Court decision,” she said. “We just approved a constitution that gives women equal rights with men. This is against human rights and against the constitution.”

Another women’s activist, who was a delegate to the loya jirga, also expressed her anguish at the developments.

“Don’t ask me what these mullahs are doing, I would be very cruel,” she said, asking not to be named.

Comment:

Is this the return of the dreaded Islamic law? Or back to afgani culture of oppressing women? Its strange how when muslims seek to protect the honour of the woman Islam comes under attack. But when the women are degraded daily in the media no one objects. I wonder what muslim women feel about this?

dont they have bigger problems to worry about rather than taking no value actions which just appease a certain quarter?

"degradation" as you call it, i.e. some women who are singers by choice appearing on Tv by their choice sure seems to be better than degradation of a majority of women by not allowing them access to education, healthcare or to be a part of the society at large.

dunya may aur koi baat nahi reh gayi karne ki, sochne ki, discuss karne ki.

lowest computer to population ratio hamara hay. lowest population to scientist ratio hamara hay. sab say ziada humein shoq hay dunya ko zayr karne ka.

aur logon ki sochein doosron kay nachne ganay tak mehdood hein.

jis afghani ney yeh ban lagaya ho ga, aur jin logon ki zindagiyon mey iss khabar say bahar aa gayi ho gi, mey yaqin say keh sakta hoon key aise loge apni zindagi may musalmanon kay liay aur kuch kabhi nahi karein gay.

I hope the Mullahs got off well. To bad it didn’t last that long.

Afghan TV wins ‘woman singer war’

Afghan state television has pressed ahead with broadcasts of women singers after winning government support in the teeth of religious protests.
Footage of 1960s star Ustad Mahwash was shown on Saturday night despite the objections of the supreme court.

Until this week, state TV had not shown women singers since the fall of the Soviet-backed secular regime in 1992.

Culture Minister Sayed Makhdoom Raheen said Afghanistan’s new constitution gave women equal rights.

On Monday, a popular singer called Salma appeared on television, prompting a letter from the court demanding such broadcasts be stopped.

Television executives decided they had gone too far, and said on Friday that the country was not yet ready for such broadcasts.

But on Saturday night, it was the turn of Ustad Mahwash, a household name in Afghanistan in the 1960s and 1970s.

Earlier, amid some confusion over whether the TV would follow the court, the culture minister upheld its right to air the songs.

“There is no discrimination and there will be no discrimination,” he said.

President Hamid Karzai said that it should be up to the government to decide on the issue, adding that there had been a tradition of women singers on TV and radio for “50-60 years”.

‘Not un-Islamic’

Deputy Chief Justice Fazel Ahmed Manawi had said the supreme court was “opposed to women singing and dancing as a whole”.

“This is totally against the decisions of the supreme court and it has to be stopped,” he said on Wednesday.

However, Women’s Affairs Minister Habiba Surabi accused the court of “interfering in issues which are not their business”.

“I didn’t see anything un-Islamic in Ms Salma’s footage,” she said. “She was just sitting politely and singing.”

Women have gradually been gaining a higher profile since the fall of the Taleban - which banned television outright - just over two years ago.

The recent loya jirga, or grand assembly, adopted a new constitution which gave women equal rights.

Since 2002, some have presented news shows on television.

There has also been a proliferation of Indian movies and cable television, which conservative Muslims have heavily criticised.

Hey if Celine Dion get's less global air time surely it's a good thing?