Re: Abdullah ibn Saba - The Myth Exposed
Quran is infallible, and Quran doesn't mention any man named Ali, not to speak of his so called Divinity. All we know of an Infallible Imam is from the Fallible source of Hadith from Fallible transmitters of shias and according to shia faith, Taqiyyah (lying) is their deen so who knows if they spoke of an Infallible 'Ali they were not doing Taqiyyah. Kindly show me a shia hadith about Infallibles which has been recorded or compiled by an Infallible (like Jafar Sadiq) himself. And if you fail to provide me a single Infallible Hadith from any Infallible then forget about following Infallibles, you can't even show me where your last Infallible is, so I can see him personally to confirm your faith.
Thats quite ignorant of you. The statements of infallible imams are of course transmitted through their devoted followers (though fallible) and thats the reason we have science of hadith through which one can examine the authenticity of the narrator.
And if you still persist with the same pathetic logic of relying only on infallible ones (in terms of compilation) then you should remain aloof from your books since they were compiled and they contain some people who's faith have always been under scrutiny, forget about callimg them "Sahih" books.
[QUOTE]
Quran is infallible, and Quran doesn't mention any man named Ali, not to speak of his so called Divinity.
[/QUOTE]
Thats true! Who claimed otherwise? !!