Re: A Stab at Classical Singing
Ha ha ha … I think that’s because there’s no music.
That actually reminds me of a joke: A Pakistani fella came from Saudi and he was telling his relatives about how nice the people are there. And he goes: I once got into a fight with an Arab. He was such a nice guy, that even though I kept cursing at him, he kept reciting the Qur’an to me. 
He obviously didn’t understand Arabic.
Similarly, you’ve taken out the lyrics and there is no music to begin with. How would it be any different than a Na’at ? 