A raped woman who cannot produced four witnesses should keep quiet about it

[diwana]

Re: A raped woman who cannot produced four witnesses should keep quiet about it

@ravage

You are merely regarding, without basis, the Justice’s denial over the (government) statistics. On the face of it its a he-said, she-said case. The two cases I cite directly take the wind out of the Justice’s claims, that he didnt come across a single case in his 17 year career. These are two cases that are both on the record, and well known where in both cases a woman was raped, could not prove her rape, but was awarded punishment for zina to be rescinded by higher courts after public outcry. Either he is unaware of common knowledge or he is conveniently misremembering. You dont need me to give you a link with reference to these cases, just google these two names and you’ll come up with lots of information on them.

I agree with you that there should be provisions for women who are wrongly accused, and women who are imprisoned and spend time on death row because they were convicted after they couldnt prove their rape and only released on appeal later (Zafran bibi). Unfortunately the moment you do that, you will go through a rerun of 2006 where Islamists will run around with banners and people wishing to introduce such ‘liberal’ reforms like you and me will beat a retreat.

The moment you present half baked, half credited sources, you are doomed.

The moment one write the hateful words like ‘islamists’, they are exposed. I know you love that word. Kehkashan did too.
The article you qouted smells of hatred.

Its like someone saying words like ‘gora’, ‘American’, ‘Western’, ‘Paki’, ‘nazi’ etc.

One would take the words of someone who ACTUALLY sat on the bench and processed these cases than someone who reported alleged events.

Are you saying the justice sahab is wrong? If so then what else is new with your mullah bashing/hating views my dear?

The problem here is that you got a great answer above but just want to act like, “Main Nah Maanoon”…as usual.