a question for shia bhai :)

Society Religion & Philosophy
1

no offence meant bhai saab but just had a personal question and wanted to ask, and yes ive asked this to a WANA-BE shiya imaam but he lied to me.

anyways my question is, ive heard of myths saying KALIMAH **** LA ILAHA ILALAHU MOHAMMAD-UR-RasoolULAH** ** was shown to prophet pbuh written all over the sky and ive also heard that its in Quran too .. not all together but in 2 sept verses .. and that is totaly understand-able .. but adding ALIYON WALIYON MINAL RASULULLAHI WAL KHALIFATUL FASL plz pardon me for any mistake how does that suppoz to make sense ? as i understand HAZRET ALI wasnt the first muslim HAzret AADAM was . and ive never heard of any PROPHET predicting abt Hazret ALI but have ran through several hadiths and evidences that hazret ADAM, Hazret ISSA and many other prophets predicted abt PROPHET MOHAMMAD pbuh .. so, did prophet Mohammad practiced this SHIYA kalimah even b4 hazret Ali was a muslim and if ur gona say ** PROPHET KNEW UN-SEEN ** then why there isnt no evidence of it ?

p/s: well, now they have this new KHUMAINI kalimah in house .. God knows wats next … pervez musharaf anybody ?

2

Re: a question for shia bhai :slight_smile:

:konfused:

Saarey JahaN say acha...
3

Re: a question for shia bhai :)

^ kia hoa ?

-------------> Time Pass forever with Anwaar Qureshi :~)
4

Re: a question for shia bhai :)

Am trying to get my head around the question. Ive a feeling its in there somewhere.

5

Re: a question for shia bhai :)

He wants a justification of the above-mentioned claims.

6

Re: a question for shia bhai :slight_smile:

Brother, there is no separate Khomeini-inspired Kalima, no Musharraf directed kalima on the way, and no separate Shia kalima if that is what you are trying to infer by posting links from an anti-Shia hate site like that.

How 'YOU' doin..?
7

Re: a question for shia bhai :)

dude !!!!!!!

wake up now !!! in iran they have got khumaini kalimah .. and shiya ppl dont have seperate kalimah .. u kidding me ? you can even gooooogle all this.

8

Re: a question for shia bhai :)

^ dude when was the last time u went to iran?

Baisically, the kalima shahdah is the same. The extra few lines are merely a confirmation for being shia and is simliar to the 6 kalmeh sunnis have. btw, Ayatullah Khomeini is not in the kalima.

As for the writing in the sky, and the things Prophets were supposed to have witnessed, i've no idea. but one thing i do know, you have the kalima totally wrong, so theres no wonder it makes no sense.

**
[quote]
ALIYON WALIYON MINAL RASULULLAHI WAL KHALIFATUL FASL** plz pardon me for any mistake how does that suppoz to make sense ?
[/quote]

9

Re: a question for shia bhai :)

I guess no shia brother can shed some light on this or maybe they are still trying to find the answer. Well it be interesting to see what is true and whats not. Curious

Mr Bombastic: meanwhile would you like to tell us how did you find out that WANA-BE shiya imaam lied to you?

10

Re: a question for shia bhai :slight_smile:

I think the question has been answered by Ma Mooli. Hence, there is no reason to further indulge in any argumentation over it.