A legend in limbo

Pakistan seem bent on denying Inzamam a graceful exit
A legend in limbo
Osman Samiuddin
August 2, 2007

Inzamam-ul-Haq is in limbo. Behind him lies the vast expanse of a career well constructed. If he isn’t Pakistan’s greatest batsman, he is close. A World Cup winner, his captaincy tenure, in terms of matches led, is third-longest in Tests and ODIs; only Imran Khan, Javed Miandad and Wasim Akram have led Pakistan to more Test wins, and only Imran and Akram to more ODI victories.

In front of him, at 37 and having given up green pyjamas and the captaincy, lies uncertainty. Less than a mile from where he is staying on a short trip to Karachi, in a training camp at the National Stadium, Pakistan cricket is going back to the future and, like the film franchise, it gets less funny each time it does so. The papers say he is not part of any future, yet Inzamam, and many others, believe he still has a future.

Naturally, he is unruffled but as he nears his end the immediate past weighs on him. Bob Woolmer recollections flow, even a hint slipped in that all was not well towards the end. “It does not matter how we worked together, despite everything Bob managed to gel together a young side. He was completely committed and genuine about it.”

A laughing acknowledgment too of Woolmer’s media savvy: **“I never used to read the papers towards the end, but only because I knew that Bob would’ve read everything on the net and was waiting to tell me.” **

If it turns out that we don’t see Inzamam again, his last moments will have been his lowest. He decided to retire after the loss to Ireland and Woolmer’s death, and though it was taken in haste, he does not regret the decision. The thought of not being captain anymore prompts a broad grin: “Thank god.” He was always reluctant.

And you just know he doesn’t envy Shoaib Malik, whose prospects, Inzamam philosophises, depend as much off the field as on it. “It’s one thing I learned: on the field is one thing, but off it is another altogether. Handling the media, the attention, the players, the board, dressing-room spirit: a good captain is one who can handle both well.” Like his batting, it is a subtle but powerful tip.

“He’s just started and he needs more time. He needs to be supported by the board and by his players. In Pakistan cricket, the real test comes when the team is not doing well. When it is winning, everything is fine. It is when you are losing that the captain has to keep the players together. He has to fight for them.”

Though Inzamam is lighter in heart, mood and weight, the immediate future also weighs on him. Details need not be publicised but he feels slighted by moves already afoot to prevent him from adding to his 8813 Test runs: he wants to score 10,000. The selectors refuse to admit this is so; in fact, they stress the opposite. Salahuddin Ahmed, chief of the committee, told Cricinfo at the camp, “He does have a place in the side, subject to fitness. Every player has to be fit, and a fit and in-form Inzamam is an asset for Pakistan.”** The “subject to fitness” caveat makes Inzamam smile. “I played unfit all these years then?”** It’s another matter that he doesn’t have any way of proving form or fitness before the South Africa series. The domestic season doesn’t start till December; he will, he says, turn out for Lahore Gymkhana.

The truth is the decision is not in the selectors’ hands. No board official will say publicly, but that they are not keen on Inzamam playing again is clear. **The policy to award central contracts was tweaked to include only those players available for both Tests and ODIs, thus excluding Inzamam. No matter that the contracted Danish Kaneria has barely played an ODI recently, that Yasir Arafat is unlikely to make a Test debut, or that Younis Khan isn’t keen on playing ODIs anymore. The Indian Cricket League’s (ICL) offer to Inzamam, in fact, prompted the board chairman to go as far as to say that any player signing up wih the ICL will not be considered for future Pakistan internationals - a stance harsher on this matter than any other board’s. **

You can perhaps understand their concern. Inzamam back in the dressing room, unwittingly or otherwise, they feel, will undermine Malik’s captaincy. They are also worried that the religiosity they have been keen to dampen is likely to resurface. Inzamam is aware of this fear: he turned down the captaincy initially because he didn’t want to handle so many ex-captains. The senior group of players he is close to remain so. Speculation that Mohammad Yousuf might be shunted out of the Twenty20 squad elicits a loyal response from Inzamam: “How can they even think of doing that? It can destabilise the entire team.”

But on paper, there is no case. Last year was a moderate one for Inzamam, but only the year before that he touched a rarified peak. And** he still averages nearly 60 from his last 20 Tests with over 1600 runs**. More importantly, who on earth replaces him? Misbah-ul-Haq, out of the picture for over three years and never really in it in the first place? Faisal Iqbal, who still hasn’t convinced entirely? Or Asim Kamal, whose promising career successive selectors have all but ruined?

Thus Inzamam and Pakistan are both in limbo, stranded between whiles. On merit Inzamam is a shoo-in, yet you wonder how his presence will affect the dynamics of a new side. **Nothing is clear save this: the Pakistani cricketer who retires with grace, dignity and at an opportune time has not yet set foot on this earth. He has lingered, he has not been allowed to linger; he is pushed, nudged, intrigued out. Often he is just forgotten. Inzamam is on the verge of joining that crowded fraternity. Perhaps he already has. **
Osman Samiuddin is Pakistan editor of Cricinfo

Re: A legend in limbo

Excellent article, thanks for posting. All these concerns about disruption to team spirit etc notwithstanding, fact remains that on merit alone, Inzi would walk intothe Pakistani team (in fact into almost any test team). Would be a real shame to see him be forced out against his will. IMO, one of the top two Pakistani batsmen ever.

Re: A legend in limbo

I think Inzamam should just retire with grace. All he wants to do is get those 19 or so runs so he could beat Javed Miandad as the highest run getter for Pakistan in test matches.

Inzi is a legend...no one is taking that away from him..but I would hate to see him back in the team because I want a new Pakistani team, a new spirit among them which I believe Shoaib Malik can provide. I'm sick and tired of watching the Pakistani team play under Inzi for all these years. He took the team no where. A couple good series is not a great achievement. When it came to the real test, like playing Australia or SA or even the WC, Pakistan was humiliated.

I've always wanted Shoiab Malik to lead the team, even when Younis was in contention to be captain. He brings a breath of fresh air into the team and thats what we need. We need a captain who is young, who wants to do well at any cost, who is willing to work hard in everything and set an example for the rest of the team.

Im sorry Inzi, you were a legend but you need to just retire gracefully and let the Pakistani team get itself up again. With Inzi back...I can see things changing. Malik won't be as authoritative as he will be with the rest of the players...and especially to Inzi because of all the respect given to Inzi. I want to see an aggressive Pakistani team...not a defensive one we saw under Inzi's captaincy all these years.

Re: A legend in limbo

Osman Samiuddin is the best writer on cricinfo. He'll be the writer for our next movie.

Ramse Brothers

Re: A legend in limbo

It is unfair to blame Inzamam for something that he did not do. He is not the reason why Pakistan lost Akhtar and Asif before the World Cup, Razzaq's injury and opener's continued failure. Moreover, the hatred we mustered because of him being religious. Pakistan performed badly due to lack of planning from PCB and it is still evident today.

We have to remember that this guy has never played for stats or records, never. So if he is willing to contribute, it is because he can.

Re: A legend in limbo

It is also unfair to blame the PCB for everything. Inzi had a lot to do with that went on. PCB has always known to curb to player power. Even the post world cup report stated that Inzamam had become a dictator, and it is very clear he did. The continous selection of Arshad Khan, the selection of Rao Iftikhar when he was not performing the way he is right now when bowlers like Najaf Shah were ignored for so long even when they were performing better... the addition of Azhar Mehmood into the world cup squad, Mushtaq Ahmed becoming assistant coach? Does it happen to be a coincidence that all these people are known to be friends of Inzi?

Like you said, the board is to blame for this and I agree. To some extent, the board is to blame that why they kept listening to a dictator for so long and let him influence all decisions. The board has taken a tougher stance post the world cup and I want them to be firm on that. They know Inzi will come back and try to dictate things like he did previously...and I'm sure to avoid that, they are trying to get the point acorss that they dont want him in the team anymore. But, Inzi being what he is best, clueless, or maybe he pretends to be clueless...still wants to come back. He should just retire gracefully like a legend should. Whats the point of forcing yourself back into the team when you know the board doesnt want you? He should have some self respect. I'll say it again, and I've said it before, all he wants to do with break Miandad's record of the highest test runs for Pakistan. If he's so fit, why did he retire from ODI's? Don't you need to be fitter to play test matches, since you're gonna be batting for longer periods of time and be on the field for much longer too? So if he's fit enough to play Test matches...why not ODI's? maybe because he doesn't have any records to break for ODI's?

I don't know if he's always been selfish or what..but in this case he is being selfish. I love Cricket and I love the Pakistani cricket team and I want to see them do well at any cost..and for them to do well...we need to get past the Inzi era...its time for a new begining under Malik...and let the youngsters take over.

Re: A legend in limbo

Yeah right..................

PCB may have been poor planners but they weren't the ones' who were in charge on the field. Shouldn't the national captain have contributed towards planning or did he play any part in planning?

Re: A legend in limbo

The team lost in the world cup not Inzimam alone. While a captain must take bulk of the blame but 100 % blame can not be thrown to him. We've had very few captains in world cricket who actually made a difference in the performance of their team. Do you think if Ricky Ponting was not the captain and someone else was would Aussies still be world beaters ? Ofcourse they would be, they have a system in place which is working wonders for them producing quality players one after the other.

Inzi still has a year or so of cricket left in him so why stop him ? If he could score runs and win us matches why stop him ? If in the process he becomes the first Pakistani to get to 10000 runs why stop him ? Personally I think he remains Pakistan's best batsman. While both Moyo and Younis has scored runs they just dont have the same class as Inzi. I doubt any of them could play with the tail as well as Inzi. Let him finish his career, Pakistan cricket owe him atleast that much.