Re: A disappointing Dr Zakir Naik
Salam ... first of all sorry for being lazy here i was just little busy with uni and couldnt respond on time ......anway after reading this post of urz\ i am kinda thinking to leave u alone in ur present condition ... You are saying That Imam Ali a.s Calimed Khilfaat In khutba 3 first of all thanks to u ... thats what u wanted me to post and now u provided the sourcce urself .. As Usual u challenged me first to bring the khutba from nahjul blagha and now u are askin Me why did Ali a.s not mention Ghadeer in khutba ... first of all it would be as me asking u .. y didnt ALLAH name his Khaliffa in Quran ...... or some stupid question anyone can come up with.....thats the difference between shia and sunni religion when u run out of words u just grab the issues like y didnnt he say it .... For God sake thats a totally childish question ... how do u even know that he was talkin to followers of abu bakar ? And he is not tryin to prove that he desrves Khilfaat miore .. he is telling us ... U taunted me for being knowlege less ... thats kool coz i dont have enough and i admit unlike u who doesnt have enough knowledge but u wud just not admit it ... Anyway from ur posts now i kinda realize it u just google search em and put em here ... dear bother reading what u post here .... Hazrat Haroon didnt die before Hazrat Moosa a..s and thats accotrding to shia history now i didnt check on sunni history yet but i will ... so before u make historial facts try to read other histories too ...
I was looking in this post, hoping to get something that is worth reading or talking about. i was disappointed.
secondly, when you write in text speak you give an impression that you are not well read, and can not spell the words. the keyboard is there for a reason. use it.
now coming to the post, as i understand.
Allah mentioning his khalifa in the Quran...he did, only that it was man, not any particular person. speaking of Khalifa, it does not mean any ruler. it just means successor. and when Umar was appointed Khalifa, he was Khalifa Khalifa Rasoolullah. since the name was getting longer with each successor, it was reduced to Khalifa. that was just like the name of Madina-tun-Nabi was reduced to Madina.
Whether Shia and Sunni Histories are similar or different, i frankly dont care. and i dont care whether Haroon died before or after Moses. that was thousands of years ago. forget about it.
and so with Ali's story. whether he deserved it or not is a useless debate. you can not change history now. and whatever you say you will never be able to do so.
so it is better if you stop fighting about it and use your energies towards a better purpose.