Re: 3rd Test: India v England at The Oval - Aug 9-13, 2007
Dhoni OUT, Yuvraj IN Dhoni scored 0 and 1 against Sri Lanka A. His wicket-keeping has been poor (though he did not miss chances in the 2nd test). It is ridiculous to leave out a hugely talented batsman (who has been amongst runs) for the sake of Dhoni.
Yuvraj Singh has not only been scoring runs, but he has been doing so quite consistently. 31 and 18 vs. Sussex, 59 against England Lions and 15 (17) + 33 (40) against Sri Lanka A. Only recently he has up the ante of scoring at a brisk rate against Sri Lanka A. He is slowly getting into his rhythm, and it will be illogical to leave him out of the third and the entire test series while having mediocre players in the side.