Why can't you criticise

[muqawwee123]

Re: Why can’t you criticise

@diwana

No idea why you keep denying what is so obvious. And no idea what history books or sources you have consulted. But you are making many blunders here bhai sahab.

You are saying Urdu should have been promoted in East Pakistan but forgetting that East Pakistan was much more uniform and consistent than West Pakistan in terms of language.

Yu keep mixing up literature with National Language and that is wrong. There is no force which can be used over any person to stop using his/her language as medium if National Language is different. Period.

Making Urdu as National Language was one of the best decision and I have written about this few years ago in one of the threads.

By no means you can use that as a criticism towards Jinnah.

OK. Lets talk about the trade community and how they were in anyways partners in division. Any proof?

it looks like you are denying the obvious here which I already mentioned.

BTW: I am in agreement with Jolie here at this issue, just to clarify.

Please answer why there was an opposition and then killings in Dhaka when Urdu was chosen as national language for them? Why agitation if their language was not supposedly affected due to this decision. I just want to understand these aspects and not here to win some debate.

Why didn’t not powerful lobbies of Pakistan stopped Bhutto from playing the role in separating East Pakistan? What power did he got? Is that lengthy report called ‘Hamood u Rehman Commission report’ just talk about Bhutto?

For role of Karachi’s business community just read the chapter ‘A legend departs’ about Yusuf Haroon in the book ‘Safeguarding Sovereignty’ by Yusuf H Shirazi (ex President Karachi Chamber of Commerce and founder of Atlas Group)