When we sold a daughter-09th Year on...

[Sa1eem]

Re: When we sold a daughter-09th Year on…

@bao_bihari

^ Please do spare some time to answer the issue at hand .

I am making my effort in this area as well alhumdolilah.

Yvone riddley and begg just highlighted the issue no one said that they themselves were present there, shaikh abu yahya libi was the first to tell about the ghost lady, which most belive was afia, it can be true , may be this was another unfortunate muslim lady, but does that make any difference.?

You are not reading the post. I wrote (and that is true too) that Muazzam baig mentioned ‘prisoner 650’ and ‘Grey Lady’ in his book (Enemy Combatant), claiming that he use to hear ‘Prisoner 650’ screaming when he was at Bagram prison. That mean, person known as ‘Prisoner 650’ was at Bagram prison before Muazzam left Bagram Prison on 2nd Feb 2003. So, in no way ‘Prisoner 650’ could be Afia, and whoever tries to claim that is lying. Now the site you posted, this is claimed, shows that whoever is running the site is lying and has no respect.

there is no terrorism charges on afia from americans ( apart form shooting incident)or is there any?

You are right that there are no such terrorism charges against her, but I am not judge to determine her prison terms. Nevertheless, charge of attacking soldier by detainees is always quite severe that could lead to long term prison sentences … that does not mean Afia did attacked (shot at American soldier)… though she was accused of that and American court accepted that.

This is where you go wrong again, why should we forget Afia when islam asks us not to forget the prisioners.

You have every right not to fight for her, but stopping others to fight for her is lame.

By forgetting Afia, I do not mean ‘stop remembering’ but what I meant was ‘to keep aside’, ‘overlook’ or ‘stop thinking about’ ‘Afia’ and get involved in other good works of stopping atrocities towards women in Pakistan, as that is direct duty of all Pakistanis, is need of time, could bring result, and could benefit many.