What was the family relationship between Hazrat Umar and Hazrat ali ?

[Sweetmoi]

Re: What was the family relationship between Hazrat Umar and Hazrat ali ?

@aqeel123

first i didnt say umar is grandfather of all muslims. I said umar was grandfather of Bibi Fatima a.s,Hence great grand father of daughters of Mola Ali a.s

2nd. we dont claim this marriage took place hence u shld know who is running the campaign against Ahlubayt a.s.

I dont understand your point at all. Even if Hazrat Umar’s daughter was married to the Prophet (PBUH), how does that make Umar the grandfather of Fatima? I think we all agree Hz. Fatima is the daughter of Hz. Khadija or am I just not getting your point?

and please, for your own sanity and the rest of us, no one is running any compagne against ahlubayt. I think this is the 10th thread I read someone writting a comment along these lines. Get out of your bubbles, you are ALL muslims. The Prophet didnt wish for his Ummah to be like this!