What is your argument against secularism?

[Naabigh]

Re: What is your argument against secularism?

@IceSoul

So you are saying that people’s Imans are so weak that they have to be kept in place through shariah laws? If that is the case, then people should stop pretending to be Muslims.

@Naabigh

Are you implying that Imans of early Muslims ( whom we call shabis ) were so weak that we badly needed these laws implemented in first Muslim state ?

@Theorist

^@Naabigh - No, they were more concerned about the spread of Islam and to make sure it stayed that way they made amendments to the existing law to show off they are the boss now. It’s been a customary thing all throughout history for conquerers. When the British occupied the Subcontinent, they implemented their own laws and called it the British Raj. When they occupied the first colonies in America, they implemented their own laws. It has nothing to do with religion. It’s more imperialism than anything

@IceSoul

This answers the question perfectly.

First she jumped the gun without reading the chain of our conversation and now you are just doing the same Anyway I have posted the chain - Sawal Gandum , jawab chaNNa

btw did you really read what she wrote ? She stated that Shaa’bis and Khulfa-e-rashdeen ( companions and successors of Hazrat Muhammad PBUH) were so power hungry that they have amendments the existed laws to show their supremacy ..

In other words - Islam laws were made by some Megalomaniac people as per their own will and wish

Well that’s a quite big allegation , my mate