What is your argument against secularism?

[The_Jinx]

Re: What is your argument against secularism?

@Theorist

It can’t be done because every group/sect follows their own version of Islam.

This is a false justification to bring secular law. Reasons may include but not limited to:

1. The rulings about System of Justice in Islam is largely the same across different schools of thoughts, it’s the same Quranic commands that everyone follows. For minor difference of understanding, there is enormous room for ‘common grounds’ as, for example, it was adopted in Baghdad.

2. Even if there is major difference that may perhaps come in case of Shia and Sunni in some issues, it is very easy to see that the ruling will be according to the faith the defendent follows.

Besides, not everyone is a muslim or is not considered one under the Islamic government. What amendments would you recommend for the existing laws against minorities and women?

Funny that you put monorities and women in the same question. Anyway, as I said earlier that laws concerning minorities can be devised according to the faith defendent follows.

Under a secular government, everybody is treated equally! And it’s not like the governing body itself will be all atheists. It will be a mix of different people of different religious background.

Thank you for saying that. Because, then, whatever a muslim criminal gets as a punishment should be the same for non-muslim. What’s your argument? Why even treat non-muslims differently and as Islam prescribes, according to their scripture? Because this is the only just way to make a law.