What is your argument against secularism?

[psyah]

Re: What is your argument against secularism?

@Theorist

See that’s what it ALWAYS comes down to. If you believe Pakistani justice system has nothing to do with Islam then why not adopt a secular law?

@psyah - I have replied to your arguments that you listed earlier but I guess you missed it. Morality is not the government’s responsibility. One doesn’t learn to be a good human being from the justice system, morality should be taught in homes by parents. Also, stop assuming that a secular government will only appoint atheists/agnostics to make decisions.

Aha a bit of reason … Theorist, yes exactly, Secularism does not see morality as the responsibility of the government … however you phrase it as though it is a universal fact … not so to Muslim we believe that morality is the governments responsiblity as well as our own.

Also I have never assumed that a secular goverment will only appoint atheists - that is ridiculous … I have never made that claim … I said that secularism is against state affairs being run by religious values … in which case whatever values are in office will be enforced … it will not necessarily be based on fairness or justice - it could just as well be based on nazism IF that is the dominant opinion of those in office at the time.