What about banking Job

[Sharaabi]

Re: What about banking Job

@pinks

I see that Islamqa has a different take then the one from Islam Online…

walaikum asalaam,

This is not a rare case where Islamqa and other Ahle Sunnah wal Jamaah scholars would differ from what IslamOnline publishes.

@burqaposhx

Awright! Then submit your petition to Islam online site.

And make sure you start your petition as:

Dr. Sharaabi wants to inform Dr. Monzer that based on Dr. Sharaabi’s doctoral research at Al-Azhar university clearly proves Dr. Monzer as wrong and ignorant of the basic tenants of Islam.

Believe me everyone will bow to your wishes and then no body will work for any bank. As a result banking industry will collapse and there will be no riba. Khas kam jahan paak.

You do not need a the two letter abbreviation two be a good Muslims and follow the correct methodology.

Who is Dr. Monzer and what standing does IslamOnline enjoy amongst contemporary Ahle Sunnah wal Jamaah scholars?

Here is a look at Dr. Monzer’s educational background:

Educational background

• Ph.D, Economics. University of Utah, Salt Lake City, Utah, March 1975.

• High Diploma in Social and Economic Planning: UN Institute of Planning, Damascus, Syria, 1967.

• B.A., Business. University of Damascus, Damascus, Syria, June 1962. Graduated with high honors awarded by the President of Syria.

• Strong training and knowledge in Islamic Jurisprudence (Fiqh) and Islamic Studies.

• Certified Public Accountant in Syria, since 1968

Source

What does the publisher mean by “strong training and knowledge”? Apparently he has received no formal education in Fiqh or anyother field of Islamic Knowledge.

We do not take our Knowledge from such people especially when the speak contrary to what the Known and Acknowledged Scholars say.

Coming to IslamOnline, i have found it lacking where correct Islamic Stance is required. I have found it going from bad to worse, and catering mainly to the Modernists and the liberalists, who need a license to “islamasize” their Haraam actions and desires.

The following statements would describe best why Dr. Monzer would give such a fatwa,

…a prohibition of working in banks places unnecessary inconvenience and hardship on Muslims both in the Muslim majority countries and Muslim communities of other countries.

Source

Comfort and Luxury, is too much to sacrifice for Islam. And that is the crux of the matter.

So Dr. Monzer can say what he wants to say but those Muslims who know that one day they’ll have to stand before Allah and answer for their deeds, the day when no Dr. Monzer will save them or shade them…will pay no heed to such fakers.