Re: The Truth About the Land of Fadak
texan dude, in the case of the verse 27:16, u shud read 27:15 and know that Allah says that He gave Dawood (as) ILM, and in 27:16 Suleyman (as) inherited this ilm from his father....
this does nto contradict the hadith of ima jaafar sadiq as mentioned above again by lajawab....
zakariya (as) also did not ask for a heir who wud inherit the property of the forefathers....
he asked only for a son who may inherit the honor that Allah has bestowed upon the bani israel (i.e. the prophethood in the family of yaqoob)
how do these verses show inheritance of property????
and even if u believe that they meant inheritance of property, why only faitma????
why did the wives not deserve the inheritance????
what right did fatima have to ask for everything for herself????
u cud not be accusing her to be selfish and greedy, wud u????