Re: The Reality of Bid’ah…
Peace lethal kamikaze
The bid’ah hasana is one that is an extrusion of existing Hadith and the long terms effects of it nourish society and bring good. Nateejah is important in evaluating this.
The real bid 'ah should not be called an innovation in English, rather it is an invention. An invention is a lie … Also, its common practice leads to a poisoning of society … Such as it takes away from remembrance of Allah …
Hence I don’t see the other language khutbahs to be a bad bid’ah …, but there could well be a hidden problem in it … Not even milad celebrations … The sciences of fiqh, setting up schools and what have you are all bid’ah hasana.