Re: The Original Shia
PyariCgudia
It very well might be the case that God did want the Ahle Bayt to be the successor of the Prophet(pbuh). What makes you think otherwise. As for your statement that if God wills X to happen, then it should happen. Not necessarily! God also wills that we muslims pray 5 times a day and be good muslims, but are we? Does this in any imply that God does not want this to happen?
It is quite an irony that right after the death of the Propeht(pbuh) when hz Ali(as) sought his right of caliphate he was wrong. wasnt he? Again right after the death of the holy prophet(pbuh) when bibi fatima(as) asked for Fadak, again she was wrong and Abu Bakr was right wasnt he? Again right afterthe death of the prophet(pbuh) bibi Ayesha fought against Ali(as), right? Again after the death of the prophet(pbuh) Mavia was right and imam Hassan was wrong eh? Again Imam Hussein was a rebel and Yazid a pious muslim.
Really it amazes me that everytime the Ahle-Bayt are the wrong ones or are taken to be mistaken but does it ever crosses the mind of the sunnis that the other could also be wrong and were mistaken. But no.