Re: Tablighi Jamaat
no no… i like to watch needless debates. 
Re: Tablighi Jamaat
^I was talking about Tariq Jamil, are you saying he claims to be tablighi but he's not?
Re: Tablighi Jamaat
yup, it is needless debate.
Re: Tablighi Jamaat
I know what you like.
Re: Tablighi Jamaat
I said you have misconception. There are a lot of people who claim to be Tablighis. Fine they can claim.
But not the one I have been talking about. Those people never get in to fiqahi issues.
i got your point.
Re: Tablighi Jamaat
I know what you like.
O really.....you seem to be some sort of pir or something with those super Karamaat powers....you know each and everything about everybody and every topic :)
Re: Tablighi Jamaat
O really.....you seem to be some sort of pir or something with those super Karamaat powers....you know each and everything about everybody and every topic :)
And you seem to be a Bi Jamalo who likes to turn everything into a fight.
The whole bloody purpose of this forum is to have discussion, what might seem needless to you might not be needless to someone else. You should learn to have bit of tolerance.
Re: Tablighi Jamaat
I would suggest the same to you…personal attacks and whatnot 
…just because you are a moderator you think you are entitled to namecalling 
…the ‘bloody’ purpose is discussion…and i am entitled to my opinion about which discussion fruitful and which one is needless…
Peace
Re: Tablighi Jamaat
This is actually the 4th time I have seen you coming up with such statement. This is not even true, which part of my post you consider as “personal attack”? the word “bloody”? Did I say Bloody NomiCa? NO. So you’re wrong.
You are too much of a drama.
I’m a mod but I have a right to discuss an issue with other members as I used to do before becoming a mod, jumma jumma aath din huye hain yahan and you think you know everything about this forum and you can actually bring it down by your silly propaganda.
Re: Tablighi Jamaat
The message below is for hareem:
Re: Tablighi Jamaat
Now don’t be deleting my posts in retalition hareem.
I like you. :flower:
Re: Tablighi Jamaat
liar.
Re: Tablighi Jamaat
Good debate. I think I need to clarify what I was trying to say, aswell.
I really respect and love Imam Abu Hanifa, he is from the bloodline of Hazrat Salman Farsi (ra). And Prophet (saw) was really close to hazrat Salman, and on an occasion he prayed for his progeny to have wisdom, hikmat, and spiritual insight. On one more occasion Prophet Mohammed (saw) said (in my own words) that Salman (ra) is like my family.
What I was trying to say was, even though the Tablighi Jamat people say that they are a sub-category of Hanafi sect/school of thought, they are completely different in many/almost all aspects. They have their own curriculum and many thing that they deem biddat and shirk are not in accordance with Hanafi school. For instance, not sending salam upon Prophet (saw), and eliminating durood from Namaz. The version of Sahih Bukhari that I observed them following is also questionable.
Anyhow, this is my personal opinion and experience, and of many other people I know. Maybe there are different factions of Tablighi Jamat too, maybe some are genuine.
Re: Tablighi Jamaat
How am i lying?
You deleted three of “you mad” posts for no reason.
And I do like you. Sometimes you’re a good mod on most days. :flower:
Re: Tablighi Jamaat
you know the pic is funny but others might take an offence to it…as i said before, nothing personal here, i’m not even allowed to move any insulting posts if they’re directed at me.
Re: Tablighi Jamaat
you know the pic is funny but others might take an offence to it....as i said before, nothing personal here, i'm not even allowed to move any insulting posts if they're directed at me.
The pic is funny - just saying that you're mad at someone. Doesn't sound offensive to me.
But hey if you are offended at that lemme know, i'll edit it out.
Re: Tablighi Jamaat
What I was trying to say was, even though the Tablighi Jamat people say that they are a sub-category of Hanafi sect/school of thought, they are completely different in many/almost all aspects. They have their own curriculum and many thing that they deem biddat and shirk are not in accordance with Hanafi school. For instance, not sending salam upon Prophet (saw), and eliminating durood from Namaz. The version of Sahih Bukhari that I observed them following is also questionable.
Anyhow, this is my personal opinion and experience, and of many other people I know. Maybe there are different factions of Tablighi Jamat too, maybe some are genuine.
I respect your personal opinion and experience. Can you please indicate me the "not sending salam upon Prophet (saw), and eliminating durood from Namaz" **from their ****curriculum.
**you are making biggest claim in this discussion.
Re: Tablighi Jamaat
The pic is funny - just saying that you're mad at someone. Doesn't sound offensive to me.
But hey if you are offended at that lemme know, i'll edit it out.
hmmm....no leave the pic, i like it. i thought it's calling someone mad rather you're mad* at* someone. but now that you have explained it to me i'll move your post back.
Re: Tablighi Jamaat
hmmm....no leave the pic, i like it. i thought it's calling someone mad rather you're mad* at* someone. but now that you have explained it to me i'll move your post back.
haha, yeh no. The whole phrase "U mad at someone" wouldn't even fit on the pic. nomesayn.
Re: Tablighi Jamaat
STA,
I dont have their curriculum with me right now, but the things that I mentioned were the main points of contention between them and other groups. I have witnessed many disputes in a number of mosques.
However, I can post hadiths from Sahih Bukhari that I have observed them following, that I find questionable. I have a copy of it and its also available online.