Senior Indian politician expelled

SID_NY · August 19, 2009, 6:53pm

Exactly, same is with some of the democrats. They are never asked to leave. This is simply a shameful act and protecting it with a lame excuse is far more shameful.

SID_NY · August 19, 2009, 6:55pm

Yes its getting pretty normal thesedays that Pakistanis have to teach lessons to Indians.. and yes the wonders continue cuz Indians keep on doing the same BS

SID_NY · August 19, 2009, 7:33pm

Exactly! This is a moral victory for Pakistan and all the Pakistanese specially those who struggled for the partition.
When they cant accept someone who praises Jinnah, how could they accept Jinnah, his ideology or all the muslims who were doing the struggle under his leadership in 47. It totally justifies the partition and also give us the lesson to protect our country from such evil people who have zero tolerance for other nations or their representatives or the people who admire them.

Punjabee_in_USA · August 19, 2009, 7:51pm

Re: Senior Indian politician expelled

Jaswant Singh has been side lined on the national political scene, and this is a good way for him to stay in the news. None of this is going to change the general Indian perception about Jinnah & Pakistan

vineshvk · August 19, 2009, 8:11pm

Really. If so God save America from the republicans.

Zero_one · August 19, 2009, 10:12pm

Looks like the guy who wtote this book has a different view than u but the critical point of it all he seems to have more knowledge than u so keep ur rant on ur side of the wall

I for one always admired Ghandi and Jinnah and will continue to do so ..... Simply for what they both achieved

But the subcontinent thrives on the misery of its neighbour rather than it's shaping own destiny to prosperity

anandan · August 20, 2009, 3:26am

how the given comments can be justified...just because a senior member of a party is expelled?

or kakaballi is hungry in looking for something equal to his own country' traditions??

anandan · August 20, 2009, 3:29am

quote a single incident when someone is killed for writting a book in india....you have mistaken us for your theocratic traditions.

anandan · August 20, 2009, 3:32am

what was 'DIRECT ACTION PLAN' of Jinnah....how can we pardon a person responsible for bloodshed of thousands (unbeleivers)?

And for people who have no knowledge of history....during partition 700000 people...Hindus, Muslims and Sikhs were 'slayed'.

anandan · August 20, 2009, 3:35am

the given quote is rather a joke.

Jinnah' Direct Action Plan left thousands dead at Noakhali and Gandhi went on hunger strike for peace in the region and actually achieved it.

CM · August 20, 2009, 5:09am

Re: Senior Indian politician expelled

So many excuses. And yes we accepted Mr. Gandhi and his views. Never agreed with them, but then again we kicked someone out of a political party for saying that.

simplyme · August 20, 2009, 6:39am

Please read the post carefully. Dont jump to conclusions on my traditions :)

simplyme · August 20, 2009, 6:45am

If the party follows a certain ideology and a person no longer beleives in the ideology then it is high time that he leaves the party on his own. How difficult is that for you to understand. Just becuase you have accepted Gandhiji does not mean anything.

Let me try and make this simple for you. Imagine you are staying in with a group of friends who do not drink. If you begin drinking and creating nuisance, it is better that you leave the place where you are staying and find someplace new to stay.

Raj_ind · August 20, 2009, 7:43am

Jaswant Singh was not expelled for his views on Mr. Jinnah. in 2005 L.K.Advani, the top BJP leader expressed almost similar views about Mr. Jinnah and he was not expelled. Jaswant singh has rather been expelled from the party coz he criticised Sardar Patel, who is an icon for BJP.

And Plz come over the habit of connecting everything that happens in India to Indian democracy.

Raj_ind · August 20, 2009, 7:56am

He was not expelled coz President of BJP wanted him to be expelled,but he was expelled when all the party working commety members were of unanimous view that he must be shown the door. They were entitled to this. However personally I m against this.

Its good that U are afraid for his life. Even good is that after few years of his life, U will be happy to change ur way how U see India and Indians.

We have ppls in India who have spoken against hindu gods, and are enjoying the status of Chief Minister of Indian state. Tolrance of Hindu India is beyond imagination. Some natural exceptions are there if U dont like to bring them up.

Raj_ind · August 20, 2009, 8:10am

Okay, contgatulations for ur MORAL VICTORY.

If U dislike double standards than may I ask U a few question?

They have already accepted L.K.Advani who praised Jinnah in 2005. He was BJP's prime minister candidate in recent elections. My question is, will U ever accept someone who sing songs in praise of Mujeeb? Or Nehru? Has someone in ur country, who hold political status akin to Advani and Jaswant singh, ever written or spoken some good words about them? If yes, than plz enlighten us.

Slickstar · August 20, 2009, 8:28am

Re: Senior Indian politician expelled

Both the Indian and Pakistani posters are debating on the wrong grounds.

anandan · August 20, 2009, 9:46am

ok....tell us what complexes are disturbing you and your like minded gentry....our democracy, your faliurs or something else....do you have a normal look party in your country.....something is really wrong that one political leader is expelled from a party in India and it has disturbed your and your gentry'sleeps....

simplyme · August 20, 2009, 9:50am

Good that we have atleast one person who understands the correct grounds. Please enlighten us...

mYsTeRiOuS_gUy · August 20, 2009, 1:13pm

It took 62 years of brainwashing to create a demon (as Jaswant said) so Indians aren't going to admit overnight that Jinnah was indeed a hero.