I dont think that is true. Didnt you ever wonder if it had to do with paranoia of few landlords in west pakistan having to loose their jaaggir. Some of the trouble Pakistan still face seem to have come from these so called lord of the people.
Im not sure what you are talking about, please clarify.
[quote]
Muslims will not have a problem if it was a muslim majority and a hindu minority. Is that so. Many centuries, muslim kings ruled much of what is India.
[/quote]
True. It does seem like the tendency to have violent communal bloodbaths is somewhat curbed when Muslims were in power.
[quote]
A country formed out just because the majority are a particular religion and then having a bloody partition themselves is a point to ponder as to how a nation can sustain itself by just religion.
[/quote]
It wasnt an affirmation that we will sustain ourselves based on religion. It was a rejection of the idea that Muslims and Hindus can live in peace, thats all. Whether Bangalies can live in peace with west pakistanies wasnt really guaranteed.
[quote]
Did creation of Pakistan solved that problem. Half of muslim population is still in India. How can you justify a two nation theory if other nation has a huge minority. Can I call those people who as opportunist leaving the rest at the mercy of Hindus.
[/quote]
Yes you can call them oppurtunist, and the others as people who made an unwise choice. But it was voluntary, so they picked their poison.
[quote]
Not all laws and India will not be able to challenge any laws passed by the british parliament pertaining to India. Again a Kashmiri can rule the whole India while an Indian in India could not have been the prime minister of England and preside over the British empire.They had two rules, one for the white british and second for the brown british in India (indians). In India there is only one rule. India is formed by the states and each state contribute to the center. Without the states India is nothing.
[/QUOTE]
The idea of an analogy is not to match very single particular. Point is India behaves like an empire towards a number of these seperation oriented provinces, which is hardly a model of governance to aspire to.