Re: Qadiani poll
Don't you think it would be a good idea to revoke the decision of declaring qadianis as non-Muslims. It would solve a lot of our problems... Problems on GS for instance...
I am not an expert in Qadianism. Just for my knowledge I have certain questions if somebody can throw some light on their belief system:
1) What was the nature of Ghulam Ahmed Qadiani's claim of being a prophet. I mean did he actually claim angel Gabreil use to visit him with Allah's revelations.
2) Did he actually claim to be a prophet or just a reformist.
3) What are the basic deviations from mainstream Islam he introduced in his new version of religion?
Anyway I strictly believe that right of judgement belongs to Allah and no mortal, state or individual, has the right to declare somebody a muslim or non muslim, pious or misguided, mushrik or ahleimaan. All the revelations should be read to take guidance and not to judge somebody. In my opinion judging an individual in the matters of religion is a shirk because it is taking the task of Allah in one's own hands.
I think matters of religious choices should be left to individuals and state should not declare them muslims. Infact state should not declare anybody muslim or non muslim for that matter....