Pakistani woman dies after forceps removed

Re: Pakistani woman dies after forceps removed

Ditto, during surgery, the surgeon is dealing with 30 different types of instruments, either holding organs in place, or separating target area away from other tissue. This is why ALL gauzes used are hung separately and counted, same thing with all the instruments. There’s a checklist towards the end, where everything must be counted. Somebody didn’t do their job properly. It’s team work, where there’s multiple people involved and everyone has a duty. There’s someone at the end who checks n counts.

Nonetheless, it should’ve never happened. sigh. May she rest in peace.

Re: Pakistani woman dies after forceps removed

SHe should not have gone back to the same hospital that left them in there in the first place!!!!

Its very very sad...

Re: Pakistani woman dies after forceps removed

I have heard of so many of these stories that if I were a woman in pakistan i would do a at-home delivery :o

Re: Pakistani woman dies after forceps removed

^
just wait...till you hear about the horror stories in those cases shudders

Re: Pakistani woman dies after forceps removed

^ Yes once a dai(mid wife)...got a case where the baby's head got stuck...instead of taking her to the hospital...she tried to handle the case herself...while trying to pull the baby,the head was seperated at the neck & the baby died..

Re: Pakistani woman dies after forceps removed

now thats a horrible case :S

Re: Pakistani woman dies after forceps removed

Well if we sit down and think about it -guys this is how hear death was planned. Us as humans we just needed a way to give our selves closure...

i am sure those doctors didnt leave it there on purpose..

Plus to get back to few guppies who claimed its not easy to remember and all that. Listen guys you spent over 200K on your med school and residency to get perfect etc. to become a surgeon i believe you need to spend even few more years. We pay close to 50k or sometimes even more for the surgeory here in USA. we expect good results.

May be its easier for us to sit here and say these things i cant imagine what that husband is going through or the girls mother and how that child is going to live for rest of his life without a mother....

Sometimes you meet certain doctors or surgeons that you don't like. Someone close to me went through a recent surgeory. We had a luxury [since we live here in US] of going from one doctor to another until we felt comfortable. Found the surgeon who we thought was good also known for what he does and after that left everything up to Allah.

Re: Pakistani woman dies after forceps removed

Nia we cant comfort anyone by saying the doctors did not leave it their on purpose because this is a case of carelessness, and that is not good enough.

I find it hard to accept that this was how her death was planned. Allah does not plan things like that, if thats the case then murder victims are just plain victims of Allah’s planning? I dont think so, if thats the case then murderers should walk free afterall Allah planned it?

I just think the doctors and medical team performance was not good enough, serious action should be taken.

Re: Pakistani woman dies after forceps removed

rizu i know its very harsh to say that... i dont think anyone would have a heart to say something like that to someone who just lost a loved one-
but if you start thinking deeply the reason the purpose behind the death etc....

but rizwan it has been written that Allah has prepared everything for us. When a child is born right there at that moment his death has been written as well.

I understand your view but i look at it from a different view. I am not saying they should nto be carefull.. they must - but...

Re: Pakistani woman dies after forceps removed

Now u r getting cruel bro.......

C- section or Z- section......but to leave forceps......plzzzzzzzzz
n for one yr.......wat was tht hospital doin .......dont they check their instruments on daily basis.......no body came to know tht a forceps is missing.....

Re: Pakistani woman dies after forceps removed

I'm going to medical school in pakistan at the moment and the problem here lies in the fact that doctors feel superior to every other citizen in the country which is the main problem. They look towards their work/surgery as something they do and get over with and move on. If they would consider the person their operating on as a real human being that could possibly be their own sister/brother etc they might treat them differently.

Re: Pakistani woman dies after forceps removed

It doesnt ONLY happen in Pakistan. I have been to a few surgeries where the patient had to be reopened because the equipment count at the end of the surgery is not complete. And things have been removed after surgery.

Re: Pakistani woman dies after forceps removed

I’m not talking about this incident in particular, more about the entire country where medical negligence is very high yet there is nothing most people can do about it

Re: Pakistani woman dies after forceps removed

Well Yusuf, I hope the new generation of doctors start thinking the same way as you.

Re: Pakistani woman dies after forceps removed

i’ve met a lot of doctor like that:rolleyes:…allah ka shukar hai, i’m very learnt in medical stuff, so as i began to speak their language they begin to take serioulsy…but that’s so sad how they treat people sometimes:(…and i’m not in pak:D (france)

Re: Pakistani woman dies after forceps removed

O MY GOD...freaken doctors

Re: Pakistani woman dies after forceps removed

A hanood?

Re: Pakistani woman dies after forceps removed

This is so sad. I think this should be punishable as second-degree murder. Doctor's very well realize their patients lives are entrusted into their hands. How absolutely unforgivable for one to be so negligent. Thanks to their no-brainer, some kids gonna have a life without a mother.

Re: Pakistani woman dies after forceps removed

HYDERABAD: Doctors boycott duties: Shahzadi case

Bureau Report

HYDERABAD, March 9: Doctors and paramedical staff of the Liaquat University Hospital boycotted wards, OPD and operation theatres and held demonstrations in the hospital and outside the press club here on Thursday in protest against registration of a case against six lady doctors of the hospital.

The Market police had registered a case against the doctors following the death of a woman, Shahzadi alias Shahida Sultana, who was operated upon for removing forceps, left in her abdomen during a Caesarean operation last year.

The boycott of doctors and paramedical staff resulted in sufferings for patients.

The doctors have threatened to enlarge the scope of the protest if the case against the six doctors was not withdrawn.

Speaking on the occasion, Dr Arshad Abro, Dr Agha, Dr Shahzad Gopang and Dr Rehmat Bhatti said doctors always tried to save human lives, adding that no doctor would endanger a human life intentionally.

They said it was not proper to suspend a doctor or register a case against him for an inadvertent mistake. They said doctors could not perform their duties properly if they were subjected to harassment.

They took strong exception to raids on houses and wards of senior doctors.

They alleged that a particular group of terrorists and blackmailers was trying to harass and intimidate doctors on different pretexts. They said that under these circumstances, no doctor could concentrate on his job.

They said the registration of the case against the doctors was based on mala fide intentions.

They demanded that the suspended doctors should be reinstated and the case against them cancelled forthwith.

Faculty members of the Liaquat University of Medical and Health Sciences at a meeting held on Thursday expressed concern over the alleged exploitation of the death of Ms Shahzadi in the media.

Acting vice-chancellor Prof Allah Bachayo Memon presided over the meeting.

The meeting noted that doctors of the university hospital were working under adverse circumstances with almost no standard operating facilities which was the main cause of such accidents.

The meeting adopted a resolution demanding withdrawal of the FIR against the doctors within three days and urging authorities of the health department to improve working conditions in the hospital.

Expressing solidarity with the doctors, the faculty decided to continue to perform duties in the larger interest of the public. However, as a token of protest, the faculty members would wear black armbands till the withdrawal of the FIR.

It was also decided to seek appointments with the Sindh governor and the chief minister to apprise them of the prevailing poor conditions in the hospital.

http://www.dawn.com/2006/03/10/local9.htm

Re: Pakistani woman dies after forceps removed

But in Pakistan there is no justice! :rolleyes: