But Balochistan is not considered Disputed Territory by the entire world. Kashmir is known, considered, and called Occupied Kashmir for a reason. :)
Sorry ,may not be by the entire world but Balochis consider it as. :)
Re: Pakistani flags fly over Kashmir - situation takes unexpected turn
Infact Balochistan has become one of the deadliest areas in the entire world.Not a single day passes without rocket attacks an shootings.
Muslims were not feeling safe ,so they created Pakistan. Now they are not feeling safe so they want to create another country (after kicking out the Kashmiri Pandits). How a country with normal sense can accept this type nonsense? India should learn from China. See in western China the authorities smashed a mosque to dust ..because they didnot act in the interest of olympics (or Acted against National Interest). Here in India some kashmiri leadres are with separatist. But Govt. gives them red carpet welcom.!!!Foolosh India will suffer again and again from these thugs.
The comparison with Chinese Muslims is problematic. That territory has never been recognized by international organizations as disputed, so India does not has as strong a territorial claim over Kashmir as China has over western China.
Although the parallel with Tibet is quite strong, do you feel China did the right thing in smashing up tibet and wresting it from India?
Wow...the army fired on hindu protesters too so hindus also dont feel safe in india. If you break the law you will be punished thats the bottom line.
How many Hindu protesters died? Have Hindu protesters been living under a police/army state for decades against their will? If thats the case then yes, Hindus shouldnt feel safe in India either.
India has about 140 million muslims of which about 5% live in Jammu & Kashmir ....... so you cannot make a claim on muslim being insecure based on what 5% os a group feels.
Its not just on the basis of Kashmir. Muslims have been a conflicted group in India for generations... whether it be Gujrat, Ayodhya or Kashmir, or the persisting squalor and underdevelopment of Muslims in that country.
[quote]
If you want to give power to the people then do the same in balochistan.
Bangladesh was almost 50% of Pakistan ..... when they decided to separate.... So you decide where muslims are feeling insecure
[/QUOTE]
I love how Balochistan/bangladesh are brought into the discussion. Clearly you feel that Bangladesh should have seperated, after all India supported that. By citing that, are you suggesting that Kashmir should also seperate, there is no moral distinction there, just the fact that it hasnt seceded by force yet?
Its not just on the basis of Kashmir. Muslims have been a conflicted group in India for generations... whether it be Gujrat, Ayodhya or Kashmir, or the persisting squalor and underdevelopment of Muslims in that country.
I love how Balochistan/bangladesh are brought into the discussion. Clearly you feel that Bangladesh should have seperated, after all India supported that. By citing that, are you suggesting that Kashmir should also seperate, there is no moral distinction there, just the fact that it hasnt seceded by force yet?
That is the view you have from outside India .... the muslim population in India is facing the same challenges as rest of the population. In some pockets the hindu population is in far worse conditions then perhaps the muslims.
You point out Gujrat .... it is one state where muslims have grown economically in last few years and have a better quality of life then a large number of hindus in rest of country. Yes there were riots in Gujrat .... it is a fact no one can deny .
As for comaprison about Bangladesh and Balochistan .... well Pakistan was created as a homeland for muslims ... did it prove to be so .... half the population seperated in 71 and a part is fighting to seperate ... is this what Jinnah wanted for the muslims of the sub continant.
India supported the formation of Bangladesh ..... but if it was only due to India that Bangladesh was created .... why hasn't Bangladesh gone back with Pakistan?
Till such time Paksitan DOES NOT understand the resaons why Bangladesh seperated ... this problem will keep on repeating in different parts of Pakistan.
India has similar problems .... but they have dealt with them in a much better way . That is why today sikhs are still a part of India and play a major role in polity and overall development.