Pakistan V England 2nd Test Match, Faislabad

[brahmachari99]

Re: Pakistan V England 2nd Test Match, Faislabad

Looks like Afridi was not out. Inzi on 99. proudpakistani007, check your pm.

[teaser]

Re: Pakistan V England 2nd Test Match, Faislabad

The commentator was saying normally Afridi walks to pavillion if he is caught and he was watching the ball as it carried to Tresco...Afridi stood there did not walk off but the umpire gave him out and thats when he walked off the wicket....

[Captain1]

Re: Pakistan V England 2nd Test Match, Faislabad

Pakistan: 354/5

[Jazba_pk]

Re: Pakistan V England 2nd Test Match, Faislabad

is ghulam commentator ramiz raja saying n e thing or shut?

[DeSiMuNdA]

Re: Pakistan V England 2nd Test Match, Faislabad

shame on the english team…very unsportsman-like to even appeal 2 false catches…i’m sure the person who “caught” the ball (bell in the first case and trescothick in the 2nd) knew it wasn’t really an out

end of the over, 354-5…

[brahmachari99]

Re: Pakistan V England 2nd Test Match, Faislabad

Akmal in agressive mood.

[truelies]

Re: Pakistan V England 2nd Test Match, Faislabad

@Jazba_pk

pakistan should deffinetly report these 2 incidents to the match refree, cuz rashid latif was banned for 2 matches, i think the ump should b banned for 2 yrs, wtf is technology there for, darrel “sob” hair always in some controversy

This is the very first thought that came to ma mind… Man why on earth cant the world see this happening!

[brahmachari99]

Re: Pakistan V England 2nd Test Match, Faislabad

@DeSiMuNdA

shame on the english team…very unsportsman-like to even appeal 2 false catches…i’m sure the person who “caught” the ball (bell in the first case and trescothick in the 2nd) knew it wasn’t really an out

end of the over, 354-5…

I still think the fielders should appeal for all catches. It’s the umpire’s job to make the correct decision.

[Jazba_pk]

Re: Pakistan V England 2nd Test Match, Faislabad

@brahmachari99

I still think the fielders should appeal for all catches. It’s the umpire’s job to make the correct decision.

true if the catch is close enough for fielder to appeal than thats y upms r praised and paid so much to make correct decision and if they have doubt refer it 2 3rd umpire!

[Captain1]

Re: Pakistan V England 2nd Test Match, Faislabad

@brahmachari99

I still think the fielders should appeal for all catches. It’s the umpire’s job to make the correct decision.

No, fielders can appeal for catches like “nick from bat/glove”, LBW …but not for catches when ball has hit ground and try to get benefit from challenged umpires.

[Captain1]

Re: Pakistan V England 2nd Test Match, Faislabad

Pakistan: 355/5 (89.0 Ovs)

[DeSiMuNdA]

Re: Pakistan V England 2nd Test Match, Faislabad

@brahmachari99

I still think the fielders should appeal for all catches. It’s the umpire’s job to make the correct decision.

theres something called sportsmanship…we’ve seen it happen often when a player walks away when they get out and they know they are out, even when the umpire hasn’t given them out…similarly, if u KNOW u haven’t caught the ball cleanly and the other person is not out, its wrong to appeal for that…i can understand something like LBWs where its not clear to the players sometimes, but catches, surely the person catching the ball knows if it was clean or not…so still

[truelies]

Re: Pakistan V England 2nd Test Match, Faislabad

@brahmachari99

I still think the fielders should appeal for all catches. It’s the umpire’s job to make the correct decision.

thats insane … there are words like “morality” or “Spirit” in dicitonary .. incase u dont know

[LahoriMunda]

Re: Pakistan V England 2nd Test Match, Faislabad

@Jazba_pk

pakistan should deffinetly report these 2 incidents to the match refree, cuz rashid latif was banned for 2 matches, i think the ump should b banned for 2 yrs, wtf is technology there for, darrel “sob” hair always in some controversy

There is a big difference, Rashid claimed a catch after he dropped it. The pictures, replays clearly showed him picking it up off the ground after dropping it. The two catches in this matches are not so straightforward. The one yesterday definatley bounced but the one of Afridi today, you cant really tell for sure if it bounced or not.

[Jazba_pk]

Re: Pakistan V England 2nd Test Match, Faislabad

inzi is usually nervous b4 reaching a hundred or milestone, takes him a few balls!

[teaser]

Re: Pakistan V England 2nd Test Match, Faislabad

I am so ticked off from Afridi's wrong decision...

[pyarilclarki]

Re: Pakistan V England 2nd Test Match, Faislabad

oh i missed afridi's innings.somebody provide me vedio of his inning plz:)

[pakiplaya]

Re: Pakistan V England 2nd Test Match, Faislabad

Hoggard to Shahid Afridi, OUT: slower ball, just outside off, tries
to run it down to third man region, goes t slip, Trescothick takes
a lovely low catch, Hoggard gets his revenge

[Jazba_pk]

Re: Pakistan V England 2nd Test Match, Faislabad

i 4 got and wouldnt wanna b quoted on this, but wasnt rashids case something like he had possesion then dropped it and picked it bak up?

[pyarilclarki]

Re: Pakistan V England 2nd Test Match, Faislabad

@teaser

The commentator was saying normally Afridi walks to pavillion if he is caught and he was watching the ball as it carried to Tresco…Afridi stood there did not walk off but the umpire gave him out and thats when he walked off the wicket…

who is the umpire …shoot him:mad: