Nalain of Rasool SAWS

[psyah]

Re: Nalain of Rasool SAWS

@Thornewood9

If a debate cannot be won then that suggests there is doubt in the matter. If there is doubt you should stay away from those things. That’s sunnah. Also no one is saying it IS shirk just that doing these things can lead to shirk. Like the example of Prophet Ilyas AS people. In the end of course it is Allah indeed who knows best.

I meant the debate can’t be won - in the sense that the protractors will either accuse the people of doing shirk based on dubious definitions of shirk or accuse the people of shirk based on dubious understandings behind the intent of the people. When the people defend themselves from one side they get hit by the other and when defending the other side they get hit by the other.

I didn’t mean that this debate does not have a clear resolution … Of course it does … the clear resolution is this:

**If you yourself have reservations then avoid it, but if you see there is possibility of it being okay/permissible then do not condemn others for it … **