Re: Mut’ah in Sunnism
Thats your understanding of the above text??!! ![]()
Whatever, thats you opinion. Actually you were so eager to copy n paste the above text that you failed to notice what he has written on the next pages.
He Writes:
You have brought to my notice that the meaning of the traditions were difficult for you to understand due to the contlicting records in various books, and it was even more difficult to ascertain whether differences arose because of difference in the reasons and motives; you also complained of having no access to a reliable scholar (of Islamic sciencest with whom through dialogue and discussion you could arrive at a conclusion, neither you had any book that could cover all the branches of
'ilm e Din to save a seeker of truth from the labour of referring to many books and which could suffice as a guide and source of spiritual light in the matters of theology and the traditions of the rightly guided true Imams (A). You expressed urgent need of such a book, and I hope that the present book would serve this purpose … Nobody is able to distinguish between one and the other tradition received from the Imams (A) except with the guidance of an Imam (or the rule laid down by an Imam). There are three ways to do this (1) Compare a tradition with the Quran. if it is contrary to the Quran, reject it. (2) A tradition that is reported on the basis of a popular belief, do away with it. (3) A tradition that is generally accepted, select it, for unanimity is undisputable. Aecording to this rule, only a few traditions ean be specified (as authentie). In the matter of traditions that are conilieting, the easiest way is suggested by the Imam (A), i.e. any one of the two you are free to choose.
read the bold text above, which clearly shows that he knew that most of the traditions he gathered (actually if you dont know, a lot of them were gathered by his students and added to the book without proving thier autehthicity under his supervision) are not authentic.
Simply Laughable!! stop waisting your valuable time on sites like allaahuakbar.net, which has nothing to do but to spread lies against shaiism.
You have’nt answered the following:
(this post is saved and uploaded to another server for record and future references)