Some people sit in the Hujra of a masjid , in seclusion and have lot of time at their hands in between prayers. They come up with stories like these which have many weaknesses . Their intentions are good that they want to teach people to be pious, but since they have no formal training in writing fiction therefore their stories are not perfect and fail to deliver the real message across.
The problem is that because of these people many many people have been distanced from religion.