Muharram Starts!!! Some Important Questions to Ask (Exclusive)

[system]

Re: Muharram Starts!!! Some Important Questions to Ask (Exclusive)

@Ripper

Again I dont understand why such allusion to a great conspiracy such as a continuation of Prophethood? hz Ali a.s. was announced as the Maula of every believer during the lifetime of the Holy Prophet (s). Hence Imamate is part of Islam. .

Ok … does it mean that imam can also issue some order regarding to shariah as shariah is ended on muhammad(pbuh) and does it necessary to obey the imam in this order ?

@Ripper

No I didnt say that..

so does not it means that imam or caliph can be from other tribe except banu hashim ?

@Ripper

Yes it is wrong. But we dont condole either…

Ok .. then does it mean that we should abstain from abusive language against her ? as she repented

@Ripper

The ayat of the Holy Book mentioning the purity of Ahle-Bayt, Ali a.s. being made the Master of every believer, the Holy Prophet’s (s) narration to hold on to the Holy Book and his (s) Ahle bayt, hz Ali’ a.s. numerous speeches where he expressed his a.s. disapprobation on snatching away of the Caliphate from him a.s. Imam Jafar Sadiq’s a.s. narrations, found in Kafi, which explicitly mention the concept of Imamate…

but al-kafi is only 40% of purity level as accepted by shia scholars and there is no chain of narrations in nagjul balagha of speeches of ali(ra) … do you not consider that the particular ahadees of immamah and speeches of hazrat ali(ra) can be in the same 60% fabricated part ?

@Ripper

Mourning the ‘death’ of somebody and commemorating the most pathetic incident in the history of Islam are two very different things…

but islam allows onlyy commemration not shouting and tearing clothes ..do you agree with that ?

@Ripper

I partly agree with that. Those who love the Ahle-Bayt will strive to follow their sunnah and should understand that ‘Azadari’ on its own is not sufficient. But to keep the message alive one should also not deter to commemorate the incident itself. Dont you agree? ..

agree with you… but the best way to commemorate is to follow thier path of sunnah… do not you think that in azadari , almost all things are “bidah” ?

@Ripper

The agreement with Mauwiya was in the best interest of Islam. Remember that the Holy Prophet (s) made compacts with Jews as well.

true.. but prophet(pbuh) broke it when jews were out of control for thier mischiefs but hassan( ra) never broke it ? can i ask you why ?