Re: Milad-un-Nabiy - Yes, we can celebrate the birth of the Prophet!
Who put the rule that If the sahabah did not do it, than it’s haram to do?
Name one scholar who said that.
Sahabah did not write the Qur’an with dots, why after it was written with dots.
Re: Milad-un-Nabiy - Yes, we can celebrate the birth of the Prophet!
Brother, All Muslims that respect the Prophet and love him and follow him, show their happiness and thank Allah for sending this great Prophet by doing Milad.
So congratulations to all Muslims for such a great act.
Re: Milad-un-Nabiy - Yes, we can celebrate the birth of the Prophet!
If you speak with knowledge, name me one scholar who said blcoking traffic to show the value of Prophet Muhammad sallallahu Alayhi Wa Sallam is haram?
Name one!
Who said spending money on feeding the poor, and reminding Muslims using loud speakers about Prophet Muhammad is haram? So no athan using big speakers, is haram too?? It’s an innovation too! and Prophet Muhammad never used it nor ordered to use it!
Re: Milad-un-Nabiy - Yes, we can celebrate the birth of the Prophet!
Good point brother. May Allah reward you.
So yes, there’s the good innovation and bad innovation.
Mawlid Innvoation is a good innovation because it does not contain any unlawful act. If anyone thinks there’s let him post it with proves.
Re: Milad-un-Nabiy - Yes, we can celebrate the birth of the Prophet!
EVERY MUSLIM benefits from this event. Except wahahbies (www.alsunna.org/wahabies.htm) and those who stand with them.
But truly they lose a lot.
Re: Milad-un-Nabiy - Yes, we can celebrate the birth of the Prophet!
What complies with the Qur'an, the Sunnah, the Ijma^ (scholarly consensus), and the sayings and practices of the Companions is an innovation of guidance, and what contradicts the Qur'an, the Sunnah, the Ijma^, and the sayings and actions of the Companions is an innovation of misguidance.
This definition of the two types of innovations was given by many knowledgeable and trustworthy scholars of Islam; among them Imam ash-Shafi^iyy, Imam an-Nawawiyy, al-Bayhaqiyy, and the Hafidh, Ibn Hajar al-^Asqalaniyy.
Hence, Celebrating The Birth of The Prophet Is a Good and Rewardable Innovation. And Allah knows best.
Re: Milad-un-Nabiy - Yes, we can celebrate the birth of the Prophet!
ahmed the sahabah did not do it, the sunnah had no eveidence for it the quran has no evidence for it so why do it!
The people who participate in such activities may be good-hearted and sincere Muslims but they fail to understand that Islam defined for us how to show our love for the Prophet , and imitating the traditions of the kuffar is not one of them.
Instead, if we really love Allah and His Messenger, we have to obey them in every aspect of our life with full conviction in the Islamic aqeedah. The Sahabah (raa) are the best generation of Muslims and the closest to the Sunnah of the Prophet , yet because of their clear understanding of Islam and Message, they never held any event remotely resembling a celebration of the birth, life, or death of Muhammad .
We should ask ourselves why is it that they never did something like this yet we continue to perform this action thinking that it is a part of Islam and a duty on us?
Is it that the Sahabah didn’t love the Prophet , or were ignorant about the importance of such an event, or is that we are so defeated in our mentality that if the Christians celebrate the so called birthday of Isa (as) then we Muslims can better that by celebrating the birthday of Muhammad . This is a great insult to Islam and to Muhammad if we try to practice our deen in the footsteps of those whom Allah has called the ‘Dal-leen’, those who are completely lost. Rather, we should look to the Quran and Sunnah and understand the duties that Allah has placed upon us and then fulfill them in the way Muhammad taught us. This is the true love for Allah and his Messenger and it is what will carry weight on the Day of Judgment.
Re: Milad-un-Nabiy - Yes, we can celebrate the birth of the Prophet!
[quote]
Who put the rule that If the sahabah did not do it, than it's haram to do?
Name one scholar who said that.
[/quote]
Until now you never mentioned one scholar that said what you claim.
I mentioned more than one, Ibn Hajar al-^Asqalaniy (The ultimate scholar of Hadith), suyouti, and many many others confirmed the reward insha'Allah to the one who celebrate the Milad, and that this event is a good innovation and rewardable.
Re: Milad-un-Nabiy - Yes, we can celebrate the birth of the Prophet!
[QUOTE]
The people who participate in such activities may be good-hearted and sincere Muslims but they fail to understand that Islam defined for us how to show our love for the Prophet , and imitating the traditions of the kuffar is not one of them.
[/QUOTE]
Trust me, those who celebrate Miladun-Nabiy are much more obedient to Allah and his messenger than all those who attack Milad-un-Nabiy event.
They liken Muslims to the Kuffar??
The kuffar worshipped ^Issa (Jesus) and they said he is the son of God!!! You are likening Muslims to Kuffar???
Fear Allah.
Muslims in the Milad Celebration, only say: Ya Allah we than you for sending this human being, the best of the creations, and the one who is most beloved to you.
[QUOTE]
Instead, if we really love Allah and His Messenger, we have to obey them in every aspect of our life with full conviction in the Islamic aqeedah. The Sahabah (raa) are the best generation of Muslims and the closest to the Sunnah of the Prophet , yet because of their clear understanding of Islam and Message, they never held any event remotely resembling a celebration of the birth, life, or death of Muhammad .
[/QUOTE]
life or death of Muhammad?
Please say Sallalahu Alayhi wa Sallam.
[QUOTE]
We should ask ourselves why is it that they never did something like this yet we continue to perform this action thinking that it is a part of Islam and a duty on us?
[/QUOTE]
Why did our Masters Abu Bakr, Omar, Othman and Aliy did not think of putting dots and harakat to the Qur'an?
[QUOTE]
Is it that the Sahabah didn't love the Prophet , or were ignorant about the importance of such an event, or is that we are so defeated in our mentality that if the Christians celebrate the so called birthday of Isa (as) then we Muslims can better that by celebrating the birthday of Muhammad . This is a great insult to Islam and to Muhammad if we try to practice our deen in the footsteps of those whom Allah has called the 'Dal-leen', those who are completely lost. Rather, we should look to the Quran and Sunnah and understand the duties that Allah has placed upon us and then fulfill them in the way Muhammad taught us. This is the true love for Allah and his Messenger and it is what will carry weight on the Day of Judgment.
[/QUOTE]
Look at the ignorance. Celebrating is a sign of happiness.
Don't you know that Prophet Muhammad ordered us to make Siyam the day of 10th of Muharram to commemorate Prophet Musa ??
The great insult is to hate this great event that honors Prophet Muhammad Sallallahu Alayhi Wa Sallam.
**
Prophet Muhammad said: "Allah preserved my nation from going unanimously astray (Misguided)".
Hundreds of millions of Muslims are all now celebrating this great event of Miladun-Nabiyy.**
Until now, no one brought any Islamic proof that states Milad-un-Nabiy is Haram, rather it was people speaking without knowledge, and they surely ought to fear ALlah.
Re: Milad-un-Nabiy - Yes, we can celebrate the birth of the Prophet!
i know what is cleary an innovation and what is quran and sunnah and making birthday cakes and disco lights with decorations in the mosque is not sunnah belive me.
I am not celebrating no birthday i am just practing islam as best i can and this birthday business i leave it for the kuffar christians i have no interest in it whatsoever.
You claim people speaking without knowledge we already stated the quran has no evidence the sunnah has no eveidence and the sahabah did no such action now who is the one speaking with no knowledge it so obvious its an innovation your proof is weaker than watered down cup of tea!
Calling people ignorant does'nt help your case because your evidence is non existent as far as i can see.
Re: Milad-un-Nabiy - Yes, we can celebrate the birth of the Prophet!
Muslims do that?
Muslims do Mawlid in mosque with disco lights and cake???
If that was ever true, than you would know the judgment of that. But to claim that Milad-un-Nabiy event of people gathered to make thiker and Islamic madih, and recite Qur’an, and feed the poor and rich … WHERE the harm, or haram in that??
It’s not haram. But some people’s illusions and imaginations take them further than this.
Again, people who claim that whatever the Prophet did not do is haram to do are ignorant and spekaing without knowledge. The are many acts that are accepted Islamically that the Prophet did not do or order to do it. And I mentioned many examples before for those who wish to learn.
Prophet Muhammad said: “Allah preserved my nation from going unanimously stray (Misguided)”. Hundreds of millions of Muslims are all now celebrating this great event of Miladun-Nabiyy.
Re: Milad-un-Nabiy - Yes, we can celebrate the birth of the Prophet!
in every muslim country I have been to, muslims DO celebrate the birth of the great prophet
Re: Milad-un-Nabiy - Yes, we can celebrate the birth of the Prophet!
Milad un nabi has no evidence to back it up there is no islamic proof for it therefore it is an innovation.
People gathering to remeber allah(swt) and the prophet(saw) mashallah good action no problem whatsoever.
People gathering celbrating birthday of prophet(saw) no evidence and clear innovation.
Re: Milad-un-Nabiy - Yes, we can celebrate the birth of the Prophet!
How do People gather to celebrate the birth of Prophet Muhammad?
By remembering Allah and the prophet, and it’s a good innovation that was inniatiated over 700 years ago. All Muslims participate in it except the wahabies who claim to be salafies.
So:
Re: Milad-un-Nabiy - Yes, we can celebrate the birth of the Prophet!
there is no point repeating what has already been said several times.
** Moderators i think this topic can now be ended its becoming a circular discusssion salams!**
Re: Milad-un-Nabiy - Yes, we can celebrate the birth of the Prophet!
What complies with the Qur’an, the Sunnah, the Ijma^ (scholarly consensus), and the sayings and practices of the Companions is an innovation of guidance.
Mawlid Mubarak to all Muslims.
Special Mawlid Presentation
http://www.anwar-alislam.be/new_alsunna_org_madih.wmv
Al-Mawlid Islamic Greeting Cards:
Re: Milad-un-Nabiy - Yes, we can celebrate the birth of the Prophet!
huh ? innovation of guidance 
Re: Milad-un-Nabiy - Yes, we can celebrate the birth of the Prophet!
Yes, this is the meaning of the Hadith of the prophet sallallahu Alayhi Wa sallam:
<
So Milad-un-Nabiy, Naat (Islamic Praises), using qur'an with dots on letters, salat and salam on the Prophet after the Adhan, and other similar deeds are among the good innovations in Islam.
Allah knows best.
Re: Milad-un-Nabiy - Yes, we can celebrate the birth of the Prophet!
milad un nabi time wasting innovation plain and simple.
Re: Milad-un-Nabiy - Yes, we can celebrate the birth of the Prophet!
I think its time to move on !
Shall we ?