Milad-un-Nabiy - Yes, we can celebrate the birth of the Prophet!

[system]

Re: Milad-un-Nabiy - Yes, we can celebrate the birth of the Prophet!

@shoaib_bilal

Innovation means that coming up with some thing new and creative.

1> Who will decide that this innovation is of guidance and not of misguidence ?

2> If innovations are legal as you are trying to say, how will u defend the Ayat from Quran in which Allah :swt: has said that today the deen has been completed and islam has chosen as deen.

****Since rabeulawwal is round the corner we will see more of such stuff.

How do you explain compilation of Quran in the period of Hazrat Abu Bakr and Hazrat Usman? When it was decided to compile revealed ayath, the Sahibee who was accorded this responsibility said that the Prophet never asked us or to do such a thing, answer given to him to him was that it is for the better. Now this is Hazrat Abu Bakr and Hazrat Umer who were the first people to do Ijtihad andintroduce a new practice which was not their in the Holy Prophet time. There are other examples also, but those who have read Islamic history and are aware how the current form of Quran came into existence are fully aware of the decisions taken by the Muslims of that time and how ‘new’ ideas were permissable.