Maulana Maudodi

[Lajawab]

Re: Maulana Maudodi

@bao bihari

Maudodi sahib had some weakpoints as many of other scholars-His book *KHilafat o malukiat * was a lame attempt in history, his definations of 4 basic terms like ilah-Rab-Deen-Ibadat etc were also considerd very controversial-

Read what he said about Prophets alihassalam

*Moosa alihassalam ki misaal uss juld baaz fatih ki see hay jo apnay iqtadar ka istehkam kiay hoay baghair march kerta chala jae *

---

Aur iss kay nateejay main sayedna yousaf ko jo position hasil hoi wo qareeb qareeb wahi thee jo iss waqt masoolini ko hasil hay --TAFHEEMAT Pg122

---

ABout sahaba

Doosri taraf hadrat usman inn tamam khososiat kay hamil na thay iss liye un kay zamana main jahiliat ko zamam e iqtadar main aanay ka mauqa mil gaya

Examples like this are sufficient to prove that although he was a genious but lack of proper religious education made him do some serious mistakees.

But also keep in mind that these discussions are not for some lay person who is a non practicing muslims- Disagreement between ulema is normal thing- We should concentrate on what good deeds maudodi sahib did - like dawah etc-
Leave the rest on ALLAH.

Wallah o Aalam

This answer should adequately suffice for all and sundry…