Know your Indians

And this man is fighting for the position of the leader of the official Opposition, and hoping that will one day enable him to become the Prime Minister of Canada? Give me a break. Pick up a history book, Stephen Harper, it shouldn’t hurt you to read a little. i hate this guy’s policies, although where i live, he has a tremendous amount of support.

**

Harper sails into storm with natives, Globe and Mail

When Christopher Columbus confused North American natives with East Indians more than 500 years ago, it was a geographical blunder that tripped him up. When Stephen Harper made the same mistake, computer data bases and other high-tech communications equipment were to blame.

The Conservative Party leadership candidate got into trouble when his office sent greetings to a Canadian aboriginal organization on the occasion of Republic Day, which commemorates India’s independence from Britain.

“As you partake in cultural festivities and events, which honour your ancestors and celebrate your heritage, I am pleased to pay tribute to the members of the Indian community in Canada,” the Jan. 26 letter signed by Mr. Harper said.

A red-faced Mr. Harper issued an apology yesterday.

The gaffe prompted the Ontario Federation of Indian Friendship Centres, which got the letter, to compare Mr. Harper to the Italian-born explorer.

“It is shameful, Mr. Harper, that you as a potential leader in this country choose such offhand forms of communication which make you guilty of possessing a poor briefing staff at best, and racist approaches to policy at worst,” said a letter from the organization’s president, Rick Lobzun. “This is 2004, Mr. Harper, not 1492 . . . the last time a man got lost looking for India.”

What Mr. Lobzun was referring to, of course, was the voyage of Columbus, which he undertook to find riches in the Far East. When he unknowingly ended up in North America, he dubbed the inhabitants Indians.

In a letter written on his voyage home, the explorer makes reference to the Indian sea, “where I found many islands inhabited by men without number.” He goes on to say that he named the first island after “the blessed saviour [San Salvador]. . . . But the Indians call it Guanahany.”

The term Indian was used almost exclusively to describe American aboriginal groups until the midpoint of the 20th century and is still used by many today, including some native bands themselves. Indeed, the federal department responsible for aboriginal groups continues to call itself Indian and Northern Affairs.

Last night in Toronto, Mr. Harper called the mix-up a clerical error. “It was an honest mistake, and my office has apologized to them,” he said.

Yeah, I heard about this.. what an idiot.
[QUOTE]
... computer data bases and other high-tech communications equipment were to blame.
[/QUOTE]
Be glad they don't have Minuteman rocket silos in Canada.. or anywhere near this guy.

Also kinda goes to show how heartless political pandering really is. The guy wants to act like he cares so he orders a bunch of cards sent out but doesn't bother or care to know why or to whom.

Though it's kinda sad that the paper feels the need to print this in its article.. I mean we're making fun of a guy because he doesn't know this.. if as a paper any of your readers don't know either.... be ashamed:
[QUOTE]
The term Indian was used almost exclusively to describe American aboriginal groups until the midpoint of the 20th century and is still used by many today, including some native bands themselves. Indeed, the federal department responsible for aboriginal groups continues to call itself Indian and Northern Affairs.
[/QUOTE]

>>Though it's kinda sad that the paper feels the need to print this in its article..<<

Very interesting point, Spoon.

i knew that some Aboriginal groups still refer to themselves as "Indians". And we still have a federal department that explicitly identifies itself with the word "Indian" in its official title.

But...your post made me reflect... i don't want to make a scapegoat out of Stephen Harper. i don't know enough about First Nations peoples in Canada, as i should. i might hold Harper up to a higher level because i expect his political position entails that he should not make these kinds of political inaccuracies, especially if he is aspiring for the position of the Prime Minister of Canada. i wouldn't want him going around the world making an arse of Canada's image abroad by repeating such gaffes.

Then again, simply because i am not in the political spotlight doesn't absolve me of the responsibility i hold for educating myself about Aboriginal discussions and sensitivities. Everyone has their own responsibility vis-a-vis this issue whether or not i am in the political spotlight.

Thanks for reminding me of this fact.

Ah, don't knock yourself.. I don't know half of their histories either. Really I don't think anyone should necessarily have to, so long as you have a basic understanding of who they are. I'm sure Mr Harper is more familiar with them than I and that he really does have a decent understanding of their history and their needs.

But that's not really the point in this drama. It seems the larger point is not that Mr Harper is ignorant, but uncaring. You said you don't like his policies. I don't follow Canuckistani politics too much but from what I know I aint too keen on him and it seems not everyone in Canada, or at least the media there, are either. So maybe folks are just looking for a vulnerability on him? I don't think that's totally it.. that's part of why the story has lingered as long as it has.. but the whole scenario just goes to demonstrate as blatantly as possible that a politician's caring is a manufactured good. Sure, we have to understand that politicians are busy and cannot oversee every action, but they should be aware of the grander scheme of things going on, especially the things that carry their name.

[QUOTE]
Originally posted by spoon: *
*
....the whole scenario just goes to demonstrate as blatantly as possible that a politician's caring is a manufactured good. **
[/QUOTE]

True.