The apparent fallacy of your argument/ reasoning lie in the double standards muslim portray when the cry out loud that Islam should not be judged based on what some (misguided) muslims do ( beliefs and practice not sanctioned by holy scripture) Then how come quran which is a book that claims eternal guidance, is accusing whole nation / a religious group of a belief which is obsolete ??? and compare it with a mainstream fundamental belief of a another religious group.
IT is like saying Muslims eat pork and christians eat pork too
^ it does not make sense, does it ?
I believe explaination by bob_chasm is more logical and reasonable. But it can not validated until it is supported with authentic reference and material. I firmly belief that the answer of this puzzle and explaination is contained in holy quran. Also i firmly believe if i want quidance from quran i will get it, sooner or later. This is my personal experience that this book read minds… it provide answers to the seekers, even if you dont know where to look for :k: