Re: Help - Book Recommendation
*..."Here we are not talking about a new fangled Islam"...
*
Would a new fangled Islam be a reprehensible Bidah??
Yes it would
So:
The follower of a new fangled Islam is a Mubtadi (misguided/innovator)
The propagator of a new fangled Islam is also a Shi'i and a misguider
Re: Help - Book Recommendation
Re: Help - Book Recommendation
Re: Help - Book Recommendation
Normally i do not see what you post but here i see you are taking a free pot shot at my People.
The crux of this matter is not shirk, as the title falsely says. The matter of giving life to the dead through the Pious Ones from the Creation is firmly established as Tawheed of the highest State and not Shirk. The particular incident mentioned here is that Abdul Qadir Jilani say his own name, yet the Miracle was still granted by Allah Subhanahu wa Ta’ala because Allah Subhanahu wa Ta’ala grants karamat to His Servants as they request. For example the moon was not split till RasoolAllah SallAllahu Alaihi wa Aalihi wa Sallam pointed with His Finger, and life was not given By Allah Subhanahu wa Ta’ala Isa Alaihis Salam blew into the things He brought Life to till He Blew!
Likewise The Example Pir Abdul Qadir Jilani is not Shirk but an example of The Love Allah Subhanahu wa Ta’ala has for The Awliya, and The YaKEEN the Awliya Have in Allah Subhanahu wa Ta’ala. The disbelievers were also disbelieving in Abdul Qadir Jilani Alaihis Salam as a Wali Allah, which is a similar circumstance to when the Prophets were given proofs of their closeness to Allah Subhanahu wa Ta’ala
Again the title is misleading, it says Barelvi but the acts of uneducated people who do not follow Imam Raza Khan Rehmatullah Alaih. The acts conducted in the first half of this video (what i watched) do look suspect, but again not shirk. For the video to be ascribed to Barelvi name then the acts must be approved by Imam Raza Khan RadiAllahu Anh. You will not find this approval
It should be noted that We Muslims are the people who initiate Hospitals with a garment of a Prophet. For His Garment to be washed and the water drank, and this method of gaining Barakat has been done with the garments of Ulema (Hanbali). Hanbalis are particularly known for this (we dont do this but) they drank the ghusl water of Ibn Taymiyyah
Again I watched half of this video, Ghaus (ghawth, ghous) means helper, it is the highest station of Awliya above that of Qutb’s (axis of the world!), it can be appreciated by non sunnis as ‘‘among the great Shaykhs who has more Spiritual States and Miracles (karamaat)’’
and the jahil tafsir done by the scholar is indeed a copy of the jahil tafsir done by jahils as the matter in question is solid in genuine islamic thought
What you have to remember is Allah Subhanahu wa Ta’ala created us so that we worship Him, those who excel in this are Given, and Given Without Measure
Couldn’t stand more then the first point of this (1min due low quality) he says those whom Mushriks worshipped are not even the Malik (owners) of one date
yet it should be known to Believers
…'Know that the earth belongs to Allah and His Messenger...[Bukhari]
and what should be his fave translation:
.. But honour, power and glory belong to Allah, His Messenger (Muhammad SAW), and to the believers, but the hypocrites know not [khan 63:08]
HONOUR
POWER
GLORY
TO THE BELIEVERS
BUT THE HYPOCRITES KNOW NOT !
Re: Help - Book Recommendation
Re: Help - Book Recommendation
Peace vroom,
Simple & easy for understanding no rocket science is in that that our Prophet 
said He left behind two things, the Qur’an and the Sunnah (Hadith), and if we follow these two we will never go astray. Means we have two superior sayings which are above all other sayings. That is No.1 "sayings of Almighty Allah and then saying of Prophet Muhammad . Before I read what Tom, Dick and Harry said, I rather would like to read what Almighty Allah and His Prophet Muhammad said.
So is this **according to you **proof that "shaitan has devoured those who claiming “Quran & Sunnah”?
Re: Help - Book Recommendation
You are one of the Tom, Dick and Harry. The biggest of Tom Dick and Harry’s - I am sure you wont disagree with this!
As i have mentioned making rulings from the Quran and Sunnah is the way of Mujtahids
My comment is elaborated on in the same post, that is what i said and meant. And the explanation within this post of yours is included among those devoured by shaitan, It is also the form of implicit Shirk mentioned in the video
Your hatred for mainstream Islam, as exposed from the tom dick and harry comment, is quiet disturbing. In Sha Allah it is not a well thought response
Never mined trying to win this argument with me you should actively seek out the view of traditional Islam on these issues. I mean how can you ignore the fact that what you are calling for is new and what has come from the past is different? Does pushing a new fangled Islam seem reasonable to you? Does calling people from the traditional communities to a new fangled Islam seem reasonable to you?
Re: Help - Book Recommendation