Re: A Most Beautiful hadith Among All The Beautiful Ahadith
wat I said is, repentance is not of no value, irrespective of the level of illness.
you try to turn it around -by turning around repentance and illness- whereas that is not possible, because we are talking about repentance, given a certain level of illness (in this case all levels of illness), you try to turn it around and talk about illness, given a certain level of potential of commiting a sin. That’s not right, because A, given B is not B, given C.
logically: (A|B) ~= (B|C), and you are violating this rule
let me elaborate a bit more, your question is:
is (A|B.C) = 0?
(A= repenting, B=level of health, C=commiting a sin), you asked whether repenting, given a certain level of health and given the potential to sin, is that of no value (0). I said, A >0 irrespective of B and C.
And now you suddenly want to turn it around and say that (B|A.C)>0
that’s not right, as I said (A|B) ~= (B|C)
note: ‘~=’ stand for ‘is not equal to’