brother AllahkaBanda
The books of hadith especially the likes of Saheeh Bukhari are a compilation of hadeeth which are intended to bring forth sharee rulings. If what you say is right then why is that hadith in the saheeh compilation?
As for people who do believe in Saheeh Bukhari such as you and I … ‘righteous’ raises a point which is valid. And so do you. It is the same point.
We can’t pick up hadith and formulate opinion this should be left for scholars … but more importantly we should understand other people have their sources from other scholars who have differing opinions and to present one side of the argument is little less than prosetylising.
When Sh. Ibn Kathir (RA) used to present his case he would more often than not present all the opinions and then state which one was his own. Surely, such a thing should done in the article posted above. It demonstrates an intolerance for opposing views and encourages disunity. We should always present both or all arguments and then explain why it is that ours should be preferable.