Do We Really Never Needed a Seperate Land

Entertainment Media
21

Re: Do We Really Never Needed a Seperate Land

^ u really think the different religions could live in peace all in one country? :konfused:

22

Re: Do We Really Never Needed a Seperate Land

^we have different religions in many muslim and non muslim countries and they all live quite peacefully, no?

23

Re: Do We Really Never Needed a Seperate Land

Dont muslims, hindus, chirstians, jews, atheists live in Canada peacefully?

Despite the fact that muslims and hindus are not politically represented in this country…they live peacefully becoz of only one reason.

They respect the law of the land, laws of Republic i.e. Canada

Problem lies when, people dont respect the law of the Land and create their own laws.

Indian Republic and Indian Constitution treats all religions equally. In fact, Indian Contitution is best in the world when it comes to religion, this is what Dr. Zakir Naik says.

India is the only country in the world, that has national holidays for all major religions of the world. As far as I know.

Can you imagine US declaring Eid as national holiday!!

24

Re: Do We Really Never Needed a Seperate Land

Check what Indian Muslims have to say, do they constantly have to prove this?

25

Re: Do We Really Never Needed a Seperate Land

^^^^

Nobody gives a flying flip about what they say?

I care what they do rather than what they say..

Your actions speak more than words.

There is small portion of muslims in India who believe in Islamic Caliphate, Ummah rather then Indian Constitution.

These people need to be shifted to Pakistan as soon as possible, even if they are not willing to.

Any Indian who does not stand for the Indian Constitition ceases to be Indian. If you cannot treat every religion equally, then you are not Indian.

26

Re: Do We Really Never Needed a Seperate Land

^aahh did you even bother watching the video????????????????????

do they have to constantly prove that they love their country? you're a bit on the biased side buddy

now this time, before saying anything watch the video k? or don't say anything about Indian muslims

so many indian muslims were freedom fighters but you don't know about them maulana azad, ashfaqallah khan just to name a few, abdul hamid who holds the highest military award for sacrificing his life for his country.....Rukhsana Kousar, Jammu's braveheart .....think long and hard about all those IMs that have sacrificed their lives for India, their country too, before saying BS like "These people need to be shifted to Pakistan as soon as possible, even if they are not willing to "

who are you to say such things to them??? they are just as much indian as you are and some even more b/c they are guarding your safety at the borders and actually living in India every single day.........they aren't going anywhere

i just get so pissed off when some say such prejudiced crap whether they are muslim or hindu, yamahaguy you shift to pakistan, what right do you have to wish sending any indian to pakistan

27

Re: Do We Really Never Needed a Seperate Land

.

28

Re: Do We Really Never Needed a Seperate Land

well I will reply soon but first u two decide what india really is.. as u both are trying ur best to hide the fact. Which has caused u clearly to go against each other :)

29

Re: Do We Really Never Needed a Seperate Land

Republic of India, treats all religions equal. Republic of India and Indian Charter/Contitution does not favor any religion.

Muslims are free to propagate, practise their religion.

I want to shift all those muslims living in India to pakistan, who do not stand by Indian Charter/Contitution.

If you cannot treat all religions equally, feel free to seek Asylum in Pakistan…

30

Re: Do We Really Never Needed a Seperate Land

i guess i'm one of those evil hindu slave owners you mentioned
:(

31

Re: Do We Really Never Needed a Seperate Land

I'm not liking the turn this thread is taking. Can we please cut it out? Cheers!

32

Re: Do We Really Never Needed a Seperate Land

Well this clearly says what you have for Muslims and it replies that YES MUSLIMS needed a separate land for their rights.

33

Re: Do We Really Never Needed a Seperate Land

:D nahi yaar I sometimes really dont get it. I know there are people in Pakistan too who like(ed) or dislike(ed) the separation. I wanted to hear them mainly why they say so. Not because of now but I wanted to know what they think was important at that time in 1947.

Although it brought you too into conversation and the point is also same. Some Indians dont like the separation because they have some humanity for every person regardless of religion but some (as you also may have observed) dont have any feeling for it. They just follow what the SARKAR say.

34

Re: Do We Really Never Needed a Seperate Land

A need ror seperate land was identified and hence we got Pakistan. I think this whole argument of keeping it one country is pointless. May Allah SWT bless the people involved in making the right decision to separte the two countries. I agree that now both counties should make the effort in building and maintaining good relations with each other and provide help for one another like any other neighbouring counties would do in time of need.

35

Re: Do We Really Never Needed a Seperate Land

yamahaguy, if you're going to send the extremist "muslim" indians that want india as an islamic caliphate then send the extremist 'hindus" like Rama sena or groups that call india a hindu country and want only hindu indians living there. these types of people that are extremists from both religious communities are insane in my eyes.

36

Re: Do We Really Never Needed a Seperate Land

thank God for partition !

37

Re: Do We Really Never Needed a Seperate Land

:k:

38

Re: Do We Really Never Needed a Seperate Land

a big :k: today’s generation is definitely happier than ever for this and i wish people would move on from constantly bringing up “partition” and look ahead.