Death in Saudi Arabia

Quite a sad story:

A humanitarian issue that concerns the dead

Rahimullah Yusufzai

http://peshawar1.com/htmls/rahimullah/rahim99.html

Ghaniur Rahman’s family in Pakistan was lucky that his body was sent home 33 days after his death in Saudi Arabia. Others have to wait longer to receive the remains of their near and dear ones for burial.

The body of Ghaniur Rahman, who was affectionately called Gulab, finally reached Pakistan on Wednesday. Some members of his family were present at the Peshawar international airport to receive his remains. It was a touching scene as the deceased’s uncle and father-in-law, Raz Gul, and brothers wept openly on seeing his body. Gulab, as his name suggests, was fair and handsome but his body had turned black after being kept for more than a month in a mortuary in the Malik Al Faisal Hospital in the Saudi city of Taif.

A number of Pakistanis die every week in Saudi Arabia. Some die natural deaths, others in accidents. A few have their heads blown off publicly by sword for trafficking drugs or for committing murder. Dying is perhaps the easy part in the royal kingdom. A long process is set in motion as relatives, friends or fellow employees start making efforts to retrieve the body and send it home. It is a costly and time-consuming exercise for the migrant workers who need to work everyday to keep their jobs and make both ends meet. Bureaucratic red-tape and legal complexities mean that it could take weeks and months before the Saudi authorities release the body from the hospital mortuaries and allow it to be sent to Pakistan.

It is not only Pakistanis who are made to suffer. It seems migrant workers from poor countries face more problems than those belonging to Western states because governments in the developed world are mindful of the needs of their nationals. In the case of Ghaniur Rahman alias Gulab, an Indian and a Bangladeshi had died along with him in the road accident near Taif. The three bodies were shifted to the mortuary of the Malik Al Faisal Hospital, Taif until clearance was obtained to hand them over to their next of kin or a friend. The unusual delay in seeking clearance prompted the family of the deceased Indian national to request his burial in Saudi Arabia. Gulab’s family was adamant that he be buried in his village, Ghundo Shamozai, in Mardan district. It took 33 long days to bring his remains home, that too after the intervention of a senior Pakistan Army officer.
If one were to go by Islamic teachings, the dead should be buried as soon as possible. The delay is painful for all concerned. It was an agonizing wait for Gulab’s family as people thronged his home to offer condolences and his wife and children, along with others, tried to cope with the tragedy. One fails to understand as to why the Saudi government cannot facilitate the quick delivery of the remains of those who die on its soil. Migrant workers also die in other Gulf states but their bodies are sent home for burial in Pakistan within days. One cannot imagine that the Saudi royal family is unaware of this humanitarian issue. It is earning ill-will for the Saudi rulers and the sooner the problem is solved the better it would be for their image.

For personal experience, one knows about the cases of two fellow villagers whose bodies were sent to Pakistan after more than five months. Mir Hassan and Karim Ghulam, again from Shamozai village in Mardan, had died young in Saudi Arabia in road accidents several years ago. One had hoped that the system would have been streamlined by now and the bodies would be released quickly now. But Gulab’s case has shown that there hasn’t been much improvement in handing delivery of the remains of the dead in Saudi Arabia. But for the help of the Pakistani army general, Gulab’s remains would still be lying in the mortuary in Taif.

The Pakistan government should take up the matter with the Saudis because it concerns a large number of people. Besides the dead, their families and acquaintances also suffer as long as the bodies aren’t released from the mortuaries and sent home. An argument could be made as to why don’t the heirs of the deceased bury their dead in Saudi Arabia, where Islam’s holiest places Makkah and Madina are located. However, it is the family’s choice and in any case the migrants have formed organizations that pay for the body to be flown home. More importantly, the issue begs attention of both the Saudi and Pakistani governments because both have a responsibility to the migrant workers who through their hard work have helped put Saudi Arabia on the path of progress and earned so much foreign exchange for Pakistan.

Is it really a 'number each week' How many Pakistani's live in KSA? Seems an awfully high figure even for Pakistani's.

According to hadith (that sunni's purportedly follow) it is sunnah to be buried in the land you die.

Could that be part of the reasoning of the govt?

What is the offical reasoning behind the delay, according to Saudi govt?

[quote]
....his body had turned black after being kept for more than a month in a mortuary....
[/quote]

Not only is it Islamic to have a burial as quickly as possible for the deceased, but it would also be Islamic to inflict as little pain as possible upon the family members of the deceased. What does the Saudi government mean by prolonging the returning of the body? What do they care whether they keep the body, it's not like they needed his body for forensic purposes, he wasn't involved in any crimes. Simple matter of returning his body to his family members.

Is it Islamic to make someone suffer more than they have to? It adds to the mental grief of the family of the deceased, if they have to wait 30 days for their loved one's body to be brought back, not to mention all the stupid arrangements and legal details they probably had to sort out for the body to be returned. Saudi government is seriously screwed up in more ways than one.

perhaps it was one out of hundred cases where some hold up had occured....

what fun do people derive by targetting the saudi government????
i can understand the west for finding excuses to topple down the kingdom (for well known reasons) but why do u ppl in pakistan have to make up such stories and then generalize it so fast????
is "saudi bashing kaar-e-sawab fatwa" announced by some molana there????

Well it happens more often than not. There are countless Pakistani migrant workers in Saudi Arabia who go there to make a better living or to earn enough to send back home to feed their families. It's indeed injustice to see the Saudi government treat families of deceased this way especially if the deceased was from a country that lacks political power to be able to influence these matters.

Islamically, it is in fact sunna for the body to be buried where the person dies but if the family wants that body transported back home, the Saudi governement should be sensitive to this issue due to the family's bereavement, burial, etc.

Saudi Arabia is not known to be a very fair country in many ways and this example just goes to nip this point in the bud.

^
however Saudi Arabia is known to be defamed with rumors (just to spoil the image of the country and nullify any muslim unity that cud come thru this country given the fact that makkah and madina lie within it) and this example just goes to nip this point in the bud....

They're Saudis. Why would they care about acting humanely?

with so many years of 'experience' behind them i'm sure both nations can come up with better ways sans the red tape to expedite this process..

mughal sahab

we dont know teh ground reality, there is this example as one event..for a trend lets look around. for all we know it could be a one off, or it could be one of many.

I lost some family member sin KSA but the families decided on burial there instead of moving the body back, but the families themselves wer ein KSA then.

i will looka round to see if there is any more info on this subject.