That is ridiculous! Do keep in mind the penalty increases each year you go without insurance. The plan you are explaining is similar to the one I had with my previous employer. It sucked! Still have medical bills to pay from last year due to the stupid insurance and high deductible. It was pointless paying nearly $400/month just for medical insurance. Now, I pay around $300/month for a much better plan. It is medical + vision + dental. Yeah!