Nothing I have said is further informed by what the student actually wrote, or whether all parties involved acted according to the law. I have always maintained that it is the law that is the problem, not its implementation, which is actually usually carried out according to the spirit and letter of the law. Whether that is the arrest of a deobandi imam who tore off and trampled a barelvi poster from a shop or this kid writing down joke answers and had the professor get him jailed.. we are seeing the fruits of the law in action. You think this is what our society should be like, I dont. You want kids and imams in jail or killed for these crimes, I dont. You wont criticize these things, I will.