Re: American Idol
^ He is a very good singer. I am sure that there are people in the Jewish community supporting him because of his religious background. And it is sad that that is going to make people question his validity as a singer. He does a good job.
Catherine has seemed quite shaky lately. And Taylor's a nut. I'm not sure who will win.
Re: American Idol
Chris deserved to be in the finals along with Catherine. Taylor is annoying and Elliot isn't all that bad. He looks weird sometimes but I like the way he sings. Can't say who will win but I guess it doesn't really matter since Chris is out.
Re: American Idol
who left now?
Re: American Idol
I don't care now that Chris is out really. I would have loved to see Chris and Taylor in the finals!
I just Kat doesn't win. She can only sing a specific type of song. Plus her performances have been just OK for the past 3 weeks. I guess ppl are voting for her looks.
Re: American Idol
Is Taylor still in?
I've been rooting for him since the very first audition that he did!
Re: American Idol
yamin is out… thank god! .. i really like him as a guy.. im sure he’s a good singer. but he doesnt have the whole package.. looks really odd
i want taylor to win cuz he’s so crazy
and catherine to win too.. cuz she’s so pretty 
Re: American Idol
^ Khawa 
it is not a modeling competition
Taylor vs Katherine Sidz! Would have been more entertaining if it was Taylor vs. Chris! Taylor is a funny funny man w/ all those funky moves 
Re: American Idol
Thank you God for sending Elliot home! 
Now Taylor could win.
He’s definitely exciting to watch and performed very well yesterday.
I agree with Rukhsar abt Catherine.
but like khawateen said, ‘she’s so pretty’
Re: American Idol
Taylor is fun and puts on a good show. But I don't think he deserves being the Idol.
Re: American Idol
Ka 33, Taylor 33 so where do Elliot's 33 go? Mostly to Taylor. Meet your new American Idol.
Re: American Idol
You never know Tums! Apparently it was a difference of 0.3 - 0.5% amongst the 3 contestants - close call!
Re: American Idol
So who’s gonna win?
I’m not sure I even care any more… 
Re: American Idol
i so wanted chris to win but hes out of the competition. So i would go with catherine now. I dont like taylor at all.
p.s: I cant believe Daniel Powter was on American Idol tonite and he sang live dreamy look
Re: American Idol
^Why can't you believe it?
Well, I think Catherine deserves to win. I don't agree that Taylor's performance of his single was better than Catherine's performance of hers. My husband loves Taylor, and I enjoy him too, but Catherine has a far more compelling voice. Problem is her performances are so controlled that they often lack emotion (except for maybe "Somewhere over the Rainbow."
Re: American Idol
Sahar coz i wasnt expecting him. I m a big fan of his :)
and yea Taylor performance is always off the hook but i love Catherine's voice. Its really strong. Taylor just doesn't do it for me. Lets c who gets it.
Re: American Idol
Soul Patrol!
Soul Patrol!
I am with Taylor, so who's going to vote for who?
Taylor hicks... aaaway hi aaaway! :D
Re: American Idol
I just think Kat has a long way to go to “brush up” on her voice. She will become a better singer over the years as Simon said.
I am not a fan of Taylor’s either but I would pick him over Kat. If Chris was in the competition then it would have been an exciting competition!
I hope tonite they bring back Mandisa and Chris to sing for us
Did anyone check out the shot of the hijabi chick? I think Ben Stiller was hiding behind her in the verrrry beginning.
Re: American Idol
I don't like any of them. As they said in papers today none of them have the 'it' factor.
Re: American Idol
they both dont have what Chris had... sighz... the good ones always get rid of early on in the show.. tsk tsk
