Re: ali sina
YES.
By the way, there's a difference between calling names and critiquing. I don't necessarily agree or disagree with Sina, I am just responding to your question. But I wouldn't expect to understand it because I have often seen you resorting to 'winks' and 'calling names' when you can't intellectually respond to other people's arguments. When all else fails, just declare the other person Kaafir and move on.
It doesn't make a difference if an ahmadi agrees with sina or not.