a matter of honor

Depends on how you want to look at it. All three are co-conspirators. I think Islamic values are that you dont cheat at all, nor allow people to cheat off of you, and if caught, you tell the truth about what happened. Why is there concern for the muslim community or that they are from a muslim community, when these actions arent really "islamic" in nature?

I think many people would choose to tell the professor that others cheated off of them, to get less punishment. Plea bargaining is very popular in courts of law. As to what I would do, I wouldnt want anyone to cheat off of me, because chances are they will get a big fat F by doing so (since I dont study). grin

You can keep thinking of it as something 'honorable' but I am not :-p In my opinion, yes it's something very nice and noble to do but it's also stupidity :-p

Shikra is duniya mein sharaafat ko stupidity ka hi naam dya jata hae ..nayk aur bhalay insaan ki idhar jagha naheen...lekin Allah to Dekh Raha Hae na....

Munni...hmmm...interesting thoughts